Davison Dermott
Station Medical Centre, RAF Northolt, Ruislip, HA4 6NG, UK
BMJ Mil Health. 2022 Jun;168(3):181-185. doi: 10.1136/bmjmilitary-2020-001432. Epub 2020 Mar 26.
Occupational stress has been studied in the military and among professional musicians but not yet among military musicians. We may speculate that military musicians are subject to military occupational stresses as well as those of the professional musician, but we do not know what the stresses of the role actually are. This study is the first to identify sources of occupational stress and measure the prevalence of music performance anxiety (MPA) among a group of military musicians.
Volunteer musicians were recruited from the UK Royal Air Force (RAF) Music Services and invited to take part in an anonymous online survey that captured demographic information, incorporated the Kenny Music Performance Anxiety Inventory (K-MPAI) and asked an open, free-text question: ''. Quantitative data were analysed using SPSS. Qualitative data were coded, collated and analysed for themes.
57 musicians (38% of those eligible) completed the survey. A prevalence of 46% for significant MPA was found. Females scored significantly higher than males. Other stressors were time constraints, the negative judgement of others, musical and military challenges, tensions between musical and military values, issues relating to promotion and existential concerns.
Military musicians share MPA, career development stressors and conflicts between career and social life as sources of occupational stress with their civilian colleagues. Military stressors include being posted/deployed or compulsory fitness testing. The hierarchical structure of the military brings additional stress when rank and promotion may not be talent based.
职业压力在军人和专业音乐家中都有研究,但尚未在军乐家中进行研究。我们可以推测,军乐手既面临军事职业压力,也面临专业音乐家的压力,但我们不知道这个角色的实际压力是什么。本研究首次确定了职业压力源,并测量了一组军乐手中音乐表演焦虑(MPA)的患病率。
从英国皇家空军音乐服务部门招募志愿者音乐家,并邀请他们参加一项匿名在线调查,该调查收集了人口统计信息,纳入了肯尼音乐表演焦虑量表(K-MPAI),并提出了一个开放式的自由文本问题:“ ”。定量数据使用SPSS进行分析。定性数据进行编码、整理并分析主题。
57名音乐家(占 eligible人员的38%)完成了调查。发现显著MPA的患病率为46%。女性得分显著高于男性。其他压力源包括时间限制、他人的负面评价、音乐和军事挑战、音乐和军事价值观之间的紧张关系、与晋升有关的问题以及生存问题。
军乐手与平民同事一样,将MPA、职业发展压力源以及职业与社会生活之间的冲突作为职业压力的来源。军事压力源包括被派驻/部署或强制体能测试。当军衔和晋升可能不以才能为基础时,军队的等级结构会带来额外的压力。