Patanasatienkul Thitiwan, Greenwood Spencer J, McClure J T, Davidson Jeff, Gardner Ian, Sanchez Javier
Department of Health Management, Atlantic Veterinary College, University of Prince Edward Island, PEI, Canada.
Department of Biomedical Sciences, Atlantic Veterinary College, University of Prince Edward Island, PEI, Canada.
Food Waterborne Parasitol. 2020 Mar 19;19:e00079. doi: 10.1016/j.fawpar.2020.e00079. eCollection 2020 Jun.
spp. has been associated with foodborne infectious disease outbreaks; however, it is unclear to what extent raw oyster consumption poses a risk to public health. Control of in shellfish harvest seawater in Canada is not mandatory and, despite relay/depuration processes, the parasite can remain viable in oysters for at least a month (depending on initial loads and seawater characteristics). Risks of human infection and illness from exposure to oysters contaminated with oocysts were assessed in a Bayesian framework. Two data sets were used: counts of oocysts in oysters harvested in Approved, Restricted, and Prohibited zones of the Hillsborough River system; and oocyst elimination rate from oysters exposed to oocysts in laboratory experiments. A total of 20 scenarios were assessed according to number of oysters consumed in a single serving (1, 10 and 30) and different relay times. The median probability of infection and developing cryptosporidiosis (e.g. illness) due to the consumption of raw oysters in Prince Edward Island was zero for all scenarios. However, the 95th percentiles ranged from 2% to 81% and from 1% to 59% for probability of infection and illness, respectively. When relay times were extended from 14 to 30 days and 10 oysters were consumed in one serving from the Restricted zones, these probabilities were reduced from 35% to 16% and from 15% to 7%, respectively. The 14-day relay period established by Canadian authorities for harvesting in Restricted zones seems prudent, though insufficient, as this relay period has been shown to be enough to eliminate fecal coliforms but not oocysts, which can remain viable in the oyster for over a month. Extending relay periods of 14 and 21 days for oysters harvested in Restricted zones to 30 days is likely insufficient to substantially decrease the probability of infection and illness. The highest risk was found for oysters that originated in Prohibited zones. Our findings suggest that oocysts are a potential cause of foodborne infection and illness when consuming raw oysters from Hillsborough River, one of the most important oyster production bays on Prince Edward Island. We discuss data gaps and limitations of this work in order to identify future research that can be used to reduce the uncertainties in predicted risks.
某物种与食源性传染病暴发有关;然而,食用生牡蛎对公众健康造成风险的程度尚不清楚。在加拿大,对贝类捕捞海水进行控制并非强制性的,而且尽管有暂养/净化过程,但该寄生虫在牡蛎中至少可存活一个月(取决于初始负荷和海水特征)。在贝叶斯框架下评估了因接触受该物种卵囊污染的牡蛎而导致人类感染和患病的风险。使用了两个数据集:在希尔斯伯勒河系统的批准区、限制区和禁采区收获的牡蛎中的卵囊计数;以及在实验室实验中暴露于卵囊的牡蛎的卵囊清除率。根据单次食用的牡蛎数量(1个、10个和30个)和不同的暂养时间,共评估了20种情况。在爱德华王子岛,所有情况下因食用生牡蛎而感染并患隐孢子虫病(如患病)的中位概率均为零。然而,感染概率和患病概率的第95百分位数分别为2%至81%和1%至59%。当暂养时间从14天延长至30天,且从限制区单次食用10个牡蛎时,这些概率分别从35%降至16%和从15%降至7%。加拿大当局为在限制区捕捞设定的14天暂养期似乎是谨慎的,但并不充分,因为已表明这段暂养期足以消除粪大肠菌群,但无法消除该物种卵囊,卵囊在牡蛎中可存活一个多月。将在限制区收获的牡蛎的14天和21天暂养期延长至30天,可能不足以大幅降低感染和患病概率。发现源自禁采区的牡蛎风险最高。我们的研究结果表明,食用来自希尔斯伯勒河(爱德华王子岛最重要的牡蛎生产海湾之一)的生牡蛎时,该物种卵囊是食源性感染和疾病的一个潜在原因。我们讨论了这项工作的数据差距和局限性,以便确定未来可用于减少预测风险不确定性的研究。