Callaghan Christian William
School of Economic and Business Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Private Bag 3, Wits 2050, South Africa.
Int J Disaster Risk Reduct. 2016 Aug;17:238-250. doi: 10.1016/j.ijdrr.2016.05.004. Epub 2016 May 19.
General agreement exists effective disaster management faces constraints related to knowledge sharing and a need for real-time research responses. Extreme case examples of disasters especially vulnerable to these challenges are global pandemics, or disease outbreaks, in which data required for research response are only available after the start of an outbreak. This paper argues the developing field of probabilistic innovation (innovation increasing probability of solving societal problems through radically increasing coordination of volumes of problem-solving inputs and analysis), and its methodologies, such as those drawing from crowdsourced R&D and social media, may offer useful insights into enabling real time research capabilities, with important implications for disaster and crisis management. Three paradigms of disaster research are differentiated, as literature is related to theory offered by post normal science, Kuhnian 'normal science' and Lakatosian 'structural science,' and the goal of achieving real time research problem solving capacity in disaster crisis situations. Global collaborative innovation platforms and large-scale investments in emerging crowdsourced R&D and social media technologies together with synthesis of appropriate theory may contribute to improved real time disaster response and resilience across contexts, particularly in instances where data required to manage response is only available after disasters unfold.
人们普遍认为,有效的灾害管理面临与知识共享相关的限制以及对实时研究响应的需求。特别容易受到这些挑战影响的灾害极端案例是全球大流行或疾病爆发,其中研究响应所需的数据只有在疫情爆发后才可用。本文认为,概率创新(通过大幅增加解决问题的投入量和分析的协调来提高解决社会问题的概率的创新)这一发展中的领域及其方法,如那些源自众包研发和社交媒体的方法,可能为实现实时研究能力提供有用的见解,对灾害和危机管理具有重要意义。根据与后常态科学、库恩的“常态科学”和拉卡托斯的“结构科学”所提供的理论相关的文献,以及在灾害危机情况下实现实时研究问题解决能力的目标,区分了三种灾害研究范式。全球协作创新平台、对新兴众包研发和社交媒体技术的大规模投资以及适当理论的综合,可能有助于在各种情况下改善实时灾害响应和恢复能力,特别是在管理响应所需的数据只有在灾害发生后才可用的情况下。