Division of Geriatrics, Department of Internal Medicine, Istanbul Medical School, Istanbul University, Capa, 34390, Istanbul, Turkey.
Division of Geriatric Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, Hacettepe University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey.
Eur Geriatr Med. 2020 Jun;11(3):491-498. doi: 10.1007/s41999-020-00297-z. Epub 2020 Mar 5.
To improve prescribing in older adults, criterion sets have been introduced from different countries. While current criterion sets are useful to some extent, they do not meet the need in some European countries. Turkish inappropriate medication use in the elderly (TIME) criteria was planned to meet this need.
In phase 1, the user friendly sets: STOPP/START version2 and CRIME criteria were combined. National experts composed of geriatricians and non-geriatricians were invited to review and comment. In phase 2, thorough literature review was performed and reference-based revisions, omissions, and additions were made. Explanatory additions were added to some criteria to improve application in practice. In phase 3, all working group members reviewed the criteria/explanations and agreed on the final content.
Phase 1 was performed by 49 expert academicians between May and October 2016. Phase 2 was performed by 23 working group academicians between October 2016 and November 2018 and included face-to-face interviews between at least two geriatrician members and one criterion-related specialist. Phase 3 was completed between November 2018-March 2019 with review and approval of all criteria by working group academicians. As a result, 55 criteria were added, 17 criteria were removed, and 60 criteria were modified from the first draft. A total of 153 TIME criteria composed of 112 TIME-to-STOP and 41 TIME-to-START criteria were introduced.
TIME criteria is an update screening tool that differs from the current useful tools by the interactive study of experts from geriatrics and non-geriatrics, inclusion of practical explanations for some criteria and by its eastern European origin. TIME study respectfully acknowledges its roots from STOPP/START and CRIME criteria. Studies are needed whether it would lead improvements in older adults' health.
为了改善老年人的处方行为,不同国家引入了标准集。虽然目前的标准集在一定程度上是有用的,但在一些欧洲国家仍不能满足需求。土耳其老年人不适当用药(TIME)标准旨在满足这一需求。
在第 1 阶段,将用户友好的 STOPP/START version2 和 CRIME 标准进行了组合。邀请老年病学家和非老年病学家组成的国家专家对其进行审查和评论。在第 2 阶段,对文献进行了全面回顾,并根据文献进行了参考修订、删节和增补。对一些标准增加了说明性补充,以提高在实践中的应用。在第 3 阶段,全体工作组对标准/说明进行了审查,并就最终内容达成一致。
第 1 阶段于 2016 年 5 月至 10 月期间由 49 名专家学者完成。第 2 阶段于 2016 年 10 月至 2018 年 11 月期间由 23 名工作组学者完成,包括至少两名老年病学成员和一名与标准相关的专家之间的面对面访谈。第 3 阶段于 2018 年 11 月至 2019 年 3 月期间完成,工作组学者对所有标准进行了审查和批准。结果,从初稿中增加了 55 条标准,删除了 17 条标准,修改了 60 条标准。共引入了 153 条 TIME 标准,其中包括 112 条 TIME-to-STOP 和 41 条 TIME-to-START 标准。
TIME 标准是一种更新的筛选工具,与目前有用的工具不同之处在于,它是由老年病学和非老年病学专家的互动研究、为一些标准增加实用说明以及其东欧起源所决定的。TIME 研究尊重其源自 STOPP/START 和 CRIME 标准的根源。需要研究它是否会改善老年人的健康。