Pylman Stacey, Ward Amy
Office of Medical Education Research and Development, College of Human Medicine, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA.
Med Teach. 2020 Dec;42(12):1330-1336. doi: 10.1080/0142159X.2020.1749583. Epub 2020 Apr 16.
Questioning is one of the most frequently used and powerful teaching strategies across levels and settings in medical education. Although the concept of asking questions may seem like a simple practice, many medical educators lack pedagogical training. When effectively executed, questioning can elicit positive outcomes in learner participation, concentration, and understanding of content. When used incorrectly, questioning can leave learners feeling singled out and not in a position to learn, or worse - threatened or humiliated. There is a lot of literature in medical education about what ineffective questioning looks like, but little about how to enact effective questioning, such as what kind of questions should be asked and how to design those questions to improve learning. The following twelve tips will help medical educators be purposeful and effective as they plan, ask, and analyze questions in classroom or clinical settings.
提问是医学教育中各级各类教学环境中最常用且最有效的教学策略之一。尽管提问的概念看似简单,但许多医学教育工作者缺乏教学法培训。如果实施得当,提问能够在学习者参与度、注意力以及对内容的理解方面产生积极效果。如果使用不当,提问可能会让学习者感到被孤立且无法学习,或者更糟——受到威胁或羞辱。医学教育领域有大量关于无效提问表现的文献,但关于如何进行有效提问的文献却很少,比如应该问什么样的问题以及如何设计这些问题以促进学习。以下十二条建议将有助于医学教育工作者在课堂或临床环境中进行问题规划、提问和分析时更具针对性且更加有效。