Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, Transformational Bioinformatics Group, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Department of Biomedical Sciences, Macquarie University, NSW, Australia.
Transbound Emerg Dis. 2020 Jul;67(4):1453-1462. doi: 10.1111/tbed.13588. Epub 2020 May 25.
Pre-clinical responses to fast-moving infectious disease outbreaks heavily depend on choosing the best isolates for animal models that inform diagnostics, vaccines and treatments. Current approaches are driven by practical considerations (e.g. first available virus isolate) rather than a detailed analysis of the characteristics of the virus strain chosen, which can lead to animal models that are not representative of the circulating or emerging clusters. Here, we suggest a combination of epidemiological, experimental and bioinformatic considerations when choosing virus strains for animal model generation. We discuss the currently chosen SARS-CoV-2 strains for international coronavirus disease (COVID-19) models in the context of their phylogeny as well as in a novel alignment-free bioinformatic approach. Unlike phylogenetic trees, which focus on individual shared mutations, this new approach assesses genome-wide co-developing functionalities and hence offers a more fluid view of the 'cloud of variances' that RNA viruses are prone to accumulate. This joint approach concludes that while the current animal models cover the existing viral strains adequately, there is substantial evolutionary activity that is likely not considered by the current models. Based on insights from the non-discrete alignment-free approach and experimental observations, we suggest isolates for future animal models.
针对快速传播的传染病疫情,临床前反应在很大程度上取决于选择最适合动物模型的最佳分离株,从而为诊断、疫苗和治疗提供信息。目前的方法主要受实际考虑因素(例如,第一个可用的病毒分离株)驱动,而不是对所选病毒株特征进行详细分析,这可能导致所选动物模型无法代表循环或新兴的病毒群。在这里,我们建议在选择用于动物模型生成的病毒株时,结合流行病学、实验和生物信息学方面的考虑因素。我们讨论了目前用于国际冠状病毒病(COVID-19)模型的 SARS-CoV-2 毒株,讨论内容涉及它们的系统发育以及一种新颖的无比对生物信息学方法。与专注于单个共享突变的系统发育树不同,这种新方法评估了全基因组共同发育的功能,从而提供了 RNA 病毒容易积累的“方差云”的更流畅视图。这种联合方法的结论是,虽然目前的动物模型充分涵盖了现有的病毒株,但仍存在大量可能未被当前模型考虑的进化活动。基于无比对方法的见解和实验观察,我们为未来的动物模型建议了一些分离株。