Weber Sarah M, Hostnik Eric T, Drost Wm Tod, Hamlin Alessandra N, Ledesma Marc A, Timperman Lauren, Hechler Ashley C, Cole Lynette K
Department of Veterinary Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio.
Vet Radiol Ultrasound. 2020 Jul;61(4):444-452. doi: 10.1111/vru.12862. Epub 2020 Apr 24.
Chiari-like malformation (CM) and syringomyelia (SM) are common illnesses that can cause debilitating neuropathic pain in Cavalier King Charles spaniels (CKCS). The current imaging modality to screen CKCS for CM/SM is MRI of the brain and cervical spine. Magnetic resonance imaging provides good soft tissue detail and contrast of the cerebellum and cervical spinal cord. Computed tomography (CT) is another cross-sectional imaging technique that facilitates brain and neck evaluation; however, soft tissue resolution does not match that of MRI. Computed tomography benefits include identification of concurrent craniocervical junction anomalies (atlantooccipital overlap) and shorter imaging/anesthesia times with the ability to use only sedation. The aim of this retrospective, method comparison study is to assess the utility of multidetector CT for screening CM and SM in CKCS as compared to high-field MRI. Three groups of observers with different levels of experience graded CM and SM based on the British Veterinary Association/Kennel Club CM/SM classification criteria. Thirty CKCS underwent multidetector CT and 3 Tesla MRI studies. Computed tomography and MRI studies were reviewed at different timepoints to minimize bias. Computed tomography has lower Cohen's Kappa agreement for each observer group compared to MRI. The intraclass correlation coefficient averaging CM and SM for all groups was excellent using MRI, while CT was poor for SM and moderate for cerebellar herniation. Greater observer experience resulted in a higher agreement for CT and MRI. Magnetic resonance imaging should remain the standard for screening of CM and SM as CT can result in misclassification and greater disagreement.
Chiari样畸形(CM)和脊髓空洞症(SM)是常见疾病,可导致查理士王小猎犬(CKCS)出现使人衰弱的神经性疼痛。目前用于筛查CKCS是否患有CM/SM的影像学检查方法是脑和颈椎的磁共振成像(MRI)。磁共振成像能提供良好的软组织细节以及小脑和颈脊髓的对比度。计算机断层扫描(CT)是另一种有助于脑部和颈部评估的横断面成像技术;然而,其软组织分辨率不如MRI。CT的优势包括能够识别同时存在的颅颈交界区异常(寰枕重叠),并且成像/麻醉时间更短,仅使用镇静剂即可。这项回顾性方法比较研究的目的是评估与高场MRI相比,多排CT在筛查CKCS的CM和SM方面的效用。三组经验水平不同的观察者根据英国兽医协会/养犬俱乐部CM/SM分类标准对CM和SM进行分级。30只CKCS接受了多排CT和3特斯拉MRI检查。在不同时间点对CT和MRI检查结果进行复查,以尽量减少偏差。与MRI相比,每个观察者组CT的Cohen's Kappa一致性较低。使用MRI时,所有组CM和SM的组内相关系数平均表现出色,而CT对SM的表现较差,对小脑疝的表现为中等。观察者经验越丰富,CT和MRI的一致性越高。磁共振成像应仍然是筛查CM和SM的标准,因为CT可能导致错误分类和更大分歧。