Witteveen Dirk, Attewell Paul
Nuffield College, University of Oxford, United Kingdom.
The Graduate Center, City University of New York, United States.
Res Soc Stratif Mobil. 2020 Apr;66:100479. doi: 10.1016/j.rssm.2020.100479.
Previous research has shown that the intergenerational transmission of advantage disappears once individuals obtain a bachelor's degree. This is known as the equalization thesis: the 'meritocratic power' of a college degree. This paper revisits the question of origin-destination association among college graduates. We improve on earlier studies by using three large sample (40,000+) of the National Survey of College Graduates, consisting of birth cohorts between 1938 and 1985. Contrary to the equalization thesis, we find that parental education and parental income are associated with substantially higher post-college incomes. An individual's own attainment only partially mediates the association through the type of college attended, but not through attaining an advanced degree. The consistency of the origin-destination estimates across three decades supports a reproduction thesis of mobility.
先前的研究表明,一旦个人获得学士学位,优势的代际传递就会消失。这就是所谓的均等化论点:大学学位的“精英权力”。本文重新审视了大学毕业生出身与归宿之间的关联问题。我们通过使用来自全国大学毕业生调查的三个大样本(超过40000人)改进了早期研究,这些样本涵盖了1938年至1985年之间的出生队列。与均等化论点相反,我们发现父母的教育程度和收入与大学毕业后的收入显著更高相关。个人自身的成就仅通过所就读大学的类型部分地调节这种关联,但不是通过获得高级学位来调节。三十年来出身与归宿估计的一致性支持了流动性的再生产论点。