Nam Sung Min, Moon Je-Sung, Yoon Hun-Young, Chang Byung-Joon, Nahm Sang-Soep
Department of Anatomy, College of Veterinary Medicine, Konkuk University, 120 Neungdong-ro, Gwangjin-gu, Seoul, 05030, Republic of Korea.
Veterinary Science Research Institute, College of Veterinary Medicine, Konkuk University, Seoul, 05030, South Korea.
Anat Sci Int. 2020 Sep;95(4):498-507. doi: 10.1007/s12565-020-00547-x. Epub 2020 Apr 30.
Formalin-embalmed cadavers have been extensively used to teach anatomy. Although they ensure the preservation of anatomical structures without microbial contamination, they are considerably rigid and cannot be used to study the joint and muscle movements. Moreover, formalin irritates the eyes and airways and is carcinogenic on chronic exposure. To overcome the disadvantages of formalin-fixed cadavers, we investigated the usefulness of alternative embalming methods using saturated salt solution (SS) and Thiel's solution (TS). We compared the three solutions based on the following parameters: cost of the embalming solution; preservation of anatomical structure, color, flexibility, and texture; and microbial contamination. Convenience of anatomical structure identification and preferences in anatomical laboratory practice were evaluated using questionnaires answered by veterinary undergraduate students. Cost of the embalming solution was the lowest for formalin solution (FS) and most expensive for TS. All cadavers were successfully preserved without significant putrefaction and were useful for teaching veterinary anatomy. Cadavers embalmed with SS or TS were superior in facilitating joint and muscle movement. Compared to FS, the color and texture of muscles and internal organs were similar to those of living animals and there was no irritating and offensive smell in SS and TS cadavers. Students preferred the SS and TS cadavers for their usefulness in identification of anatomical structures, highlighting their usefulness in veterinary anatomy education.
福尔马林防腐尸体已被广泛用于解剖学教学。虽然它们能确保解剖结构在无微生物污染的情况下得以保存,但它们相当僵硬,无法用于研究关节和肌肉运动。此外,福尔马林会刺激眼睛和呼吸道,长期接触具有致癌性。为克服福尔马林固定尸体的缺点,我们研究了使用饱和盐溶液(SS)和蒂尔溶液(TS)的替代防腐方法的实用性。我们基于以下参数对这三种溶液进行了比较:防腐溶液的成本;解剖结构、颜色、柔韧性和质地的保存情况;以及微生物污染情况。使用兽医专业本科生回答的问卷评估了解剖结构识别的便利性以及解剖实验室实践中的偏好。福尔马林溶液(FS)的防腐溶液成本最低,TS的成本最高。所有尸体均成功保存,无明显腐败,对兽医解剖学教学有用。用SS或TS防腐的尸体在促进关节和肌肉运动方面更具优势。与FS相比,肌肉和内脏的颜色和质地与活体动物相似,且SS和TS防腐的尸体没有刺激性和难闻气味。学生们更喜欢SS和TS防腐的尸体,因为它们在识别解剖结构方面很有用,突出了它们在兽医解剖学教育中的实用性。