University Hospital of Psychiatry Zurich, Department of Forensic Psychiatry, Zurich, Switzerland.
University Hospital of Psychiatry Zurich, Department of Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, Zurich, Switzerland.
BMC Psychiatry. 2020 May 6;20(1):201. doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-02612-1.
Prolonged forensic psychiatric hospitalizations have raised ethical, economic, and clinical concerns. Due to the confounded nature of factors affecting length of stay of psychiatric offender patients, prior research has called for the application of a new statistical methodology better accommodating this data structure. The present study attempts to investigate factors contributing to long-term hospitalization of schizophrenic offenders referred to a Swiss forensic institution, using machine learning algorithms that are better suited than conventional methods to detect nonlinear dependencies between variables.
In this retrospective file and registry study, multidisciplinary notes of 143 schizophrenic offenders were reviewed using a structured protocol on patients' characteristics, criminal and medical history and course of treatment. Via a forward selection procedure, the most influential factors for length of stay were preselected. Machine learning algorithms then identified the most efficient model for predicting length-of-stay.
Two factors have been identified as being particularly influential for a prolonged forensic hospital stay, both of which are related to aspects of the index offense, namely (attempted) homicide and the extent of the victim's injury. The results are discussed in light of previous research on this topic.
In this study, length of stay was determined by legal considerations, but not by factors that can be influenced therapeutically. Results emphasize that forensic risk assessments should be based on different evaluation criteria and not merely on legal aspects.
延长法医精神病院的住院时间引起了伦理、经济和临床方面的关注。由于影响精神犯罪患者住院时间的因素相互交织,先前的研究呼吁应用一种新的统计方法来更好地适应这种数据结构。本研究试图利用机器学习算法来调查导致被转介到瑞士法医机构的精神分裂症罪犯长期住院的因素,这些算法比传统方法更适合检测变量之间的非线性依赖关系。
在这项回顾性档案和登记研究中,使用结构化协议对 143 名精神分裂症罪犯的多学科记录进行了审查,该协议涉及患者的特征、犯罪和医疗史以及治疗过程。通过向前选择程序,预选了对住院时间有影响的最主要因素。然后,机器学习算法确定了预测住院时间的最有效模型。
确定了两个对延长法医住院时间有特别影响的因素,这两个因素都与索引犯罪的某些方面有关,即(未遂)杀人罪和受害者受伤的程度。结果结合了之前关于这一主题的研究进行了讨论。
在这项研究中,住院时间由法律考虑因素决定,而不是由可以通过治疗来影响的因素决定。结果强调,法医风险评估应基于不同的评估标准,而不仅仅是法律方面。