From the Departments of Anesthesiology & Pain Medicine, University of Ottawa and The Ottawa Hospital, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
School of Epidemiology & Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Anesth Analg. 2020 Jun;130(6):1450-1460. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000004602.
Frailty is a multidimensional syndrome characterized by decreased reserve and diminished resistance to stressors. People with frailty are vulnerable to stressors, and exposure to the stress of surgery is associated with increased risk of adverse outcomes and higher levels of resource use. As Western populations age rapidly, older people with frailty are presenting for surgery with increasing frequency. This means that anesthesiologists and other perioperative clinicians need to be familiar with frailty, its assessment, manifestations, and strategies for optimization. We present a narrative review of frailty aimed at perioperative clinicians. The review will familiarize readers with the concept of frailty, will discuss common and feasible approaches to frailty assessment before surgery, and will describe the relative and absolute associations of frailty with commonly measured adverse outcomes, including morbidity and mortality, as well as patient-centered and reported outcomes related to function, disability, and quality of life. A proposed approach to optimization before surgery is presented, which includes frailty assessment followed by recommendations for identification of underlying physical disability, malnutrition, cognitive dysfunction, and mental health diagnoses. Overall, 30%-50% of older patients presenting for major surgery will be living with frailty, which results in a more than 2-fold increase in risk of morbidity, mortality, and development of new patient-reported disability. The Clinical Frailty Scale appears to be the most feasible frailty instrument for use before surgery; however, evidence suggests that predictive accuracy does not differ significantly between frailty instruments such as the Fried Phenotype, Edmonton Frail Scale, and Frailty Index. Identification of physical dysfunction may allow for optimization via exercise prehabilitation, while nutritional supplementation could be considered with a positive screen for malnutrition. The Hospital Elder Life Program shows promise for delirium prevention, while individuals with mental health and or other psychosocial stressors may derive particular benefit from multidisciplinary care and preadmission discharge planning. Robust trials are still required to provide definitive evidence supporting these interventions and minimal data are available to guide management during the intra- and postoperative phases. Improving the care and outcomes of older people with frailty represents a key opportunity for anesthesiologists and perioperative scientists.
衰弱是一种多维综合征,其特征为储备减少和对压力源的抵抗力降低。衰弱的人易受压力源影响,而手术带来的压力与不良结果风险增加和更高水平的资源利用相关。随着西方人口的迅速老龄化,越来越多患有衰弱的老年人因手术而就诊。这意味着麻醉师和其他围手术期临床医生需要熟悉衰弱,包括其评估、表现和优化策略。我们对围手术期临床医生进行了衰弱的叙述性综述。该综述将使读者熟悉衰弱的概念,讨论手术前常见且可行的衰弱评估方法,并描述衰弱与常见测量不良结果的相对和绝对关联,包括发病率和死亡率,以及与功能、残疾和生活质量相关的患者为中心和报告的结果。提出了一种术前优化的方法,包括衰弱评估,然后确定潜在的身体残疾、营养不良、认知功能障碍和精神健康诊断。总体而言,50%的接受大手术的老年患者将患有衰弱,这会使发病率、死亡率和新出现的患者报告残疾的风险增加一倍以上。临床衰弱量表似乎是最适合在手术前使用的衰弱工具;然而,有证据表明,如 Fried 表型、埃德蒙顿衰弱量表和衰弱指数等不同的衰弱工具的预测准确性没有显著差异。识别身体功能障碍可以通过术前康复锻炼来进行优化,而对于营养不良的阳性筛查可以考虑进行营养补充。医院老年生活计划在预防谵妄方面显示出前景,而有精神健康和/或其他心理社会压力源的个体可能会从多学科护理和入院前出院计划中获得特别受益。仍需要进行强有力的试验来提供支持这些干预措施的明确证据,并且在围手术期阶段管理方面数据很少。改善患有衰弱的老年人的护理和结局是麻醉师和围手术期科学家的一个关键机会。