Attallah Omneya
Department of Electronics and Communications, College of Engineering and Technology, Arab Academy for Science, Technology and Maritime Transport, Alexandria 1029, Egypt.
Diagnostics (Basel). 2020 May 9;10(5):292. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics10050292.
Currently, mental stress is a common social problem affecting people. Stress reduces human functionality during routine work and may lead to severe health defects. Detecting stress is important in education and industry to determine the efficiency of teaching, to improve education, and to reduce risks from human errors that might occur due to workers' stressful situations. Therefore, the early detection of mental stress using machine learning (ML) techniques is essential to prevent illness and health problems, improve quality of education, and improve industrial safety. The human brain is the main target of mental stress. For this reason, an ML system is proposed which investigates electroencephalogram (EEG) signal for thirty-six participants. Extracting useful features is essential for an efficient mental stress detection (MSD) system. Thus, this framework introduces a hybrid feature-set that feeds five ML classifiers to detect stress and non-stress states, and classify stress levels. To produce a reliable, practical, and efficient MSD system with a reduced number of electrodes, the proposed MSD scheme investigates the electrodes placements on different sites on the scalp and selects that site which has the higher impact on the accuracy of the system. Principal Component analysis is employed also, to reduce the features extracted from such electrodes to lower model complexity, where the optimal number of principal components is examined using sequential forward procedure. Furthermore, it examines the minimum number of electrodes placed on the site which has greater impact on stress detection and evaluation. To test the effectiveness of the proposed system, the results are compared with other feature extraction methods shown in literature. They are also compared with state-of-the-art techniques recorded for stress detection. The highest accuracies achieved in this study are 99.9%(sd = 0.015) and 99.26% (sd = 0.08) for identifying stress and non-stress states, and distinguishing between stress levels, respectively, using only two frontal brain electrodes for detecting stress and non-stress, and three frontal electrodes for evaluating stress levels respectively. The results show that the proposed system is reliable as the sensitivity is 99.9(0.064), 98.35(0.27), specificity is 99.94(0.02), 99.6(0.05), precision is 99.94(0.06), 98.9(0.23), and the diagnostics odd ratio (DOR) is ≥ 100 for detecting stress and non-stress, and evaluating stress levels respectively. This shows that the proposed framework has compelling performance and can be employed for stress detection and evaluation in medical, educational and industrial fields. Finally, the results verified the efficiency and reliability of the proposed system in predicting stress and non-stress on new patients, as the accuracy achieved 98.48% (sd = 1.12), sensitivity = 97.78% (sd = 1.84), specificity = 97.75% (sd = 2.05), precision = 99.26% (sd = 0.67), and DOR ≥ 100 using only two frontal electrodes.
目前,精神压力是影响人们的一个常见社会问题。压力会降低日常工作中的人类机能,并可能导致严重的健康缺陷。在教育和工业领域,检测压力对于确定教学效率、改善教育以及降低因工人压力状况可能导致的人为错误风险至关重要。因此,使用机器学习(ML)技术早期检测精神压力对于预防疾病和健康问题、提高教育质量以及改善工业安全至关重要。人类大脑是精神压力的主要目标。基于此,提出了一个ML系统,该系统对36名参与者的脑电图(EEG)信号进行研究。提取有用特征对于高效的精神压力检测(MSD)系统至关重要。因此,该框架引入了一个混合特征集,该特征集为五个ML分类器提供输入,以检测压力和非压力状态,并对压力水平进行分类。为了用减少的电极数量构建一个可靠、实用且高效的MSD系统,所提出的MSD方案研究了头皮上不同部位的电极放置情况,并选择对系统准确性影响较大的部位。还采用了主成分分析,以减少从此类电极提取的特征,从而降低模型复杂性,其中使用顺序前向过程检查主成分的最佳数量。此外,它还研究了放置在对压力检测和评估影响较大的部位上的电极的最少数量。为了测试所提出系统的有效性,将结果与文献中所示的其他特征提取方法进行了比较。它们还与记录的用于压力检测的最新技术进行了比较。在本研究中,仅使用两个额叶脑电极检测压力和非压力状态,以及分别使用三个额叶电极评估压力水平时,识别压力和非压力状态以及区分压力水平所达到的最高准确率分别为99.9%(标准差 = 0.015)和99.26%(标准差 = 0.08)。结果表明,所提出的系统是可靠的,因为在检测压力和非压力状态以及评估压力水平时,灵敏度分别为99.9(0.064)、98.35(0.27),特异性分别为99.94(0.02)、99.6(0.05),精度分别为99.94(0.06)、98.9(0.23),诊断比值比(DOR)≥100。这表明所提出的框架具有令人信服的性能,可用于医疗、教育和工业领域的压力检测和评估。最后,结果验证了所提出系统在预测新患者的压力和非压力状态方面的效率和可靠性,因为仅使用两个额叶电极时,准确率达到98.48%(标准差 = 1.12),灵敏度 = 97.78%(标准差 = 1.84),特异性 = 97.75%(标准差 = 2.05),精度 = 99.26%(标准差 = 0.67),且DOR≥100。