Division of Research and Innovation, Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College , Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
School of Rehabilitation Science, McMaster University , Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
J Man Manip Ther. 2021 Feb;29(1):51-58. doi: 10.1080/10669817.2020.1761139. Epub 2020 May 13.
: Previous qualitative studies demonstrated that the process by which patients determined whether a response to manual therapy is adverse is very complex. However, it remains unknown which responses to manual therapy patients perceived as adverse. : To describe symptoms patients experienced and perceived as adverse following manual therapy and to explore predictors of adverse responses (AR) for the body region with the greatest number of AR. We hypothesized that patients receiving manual therapy for neck conditions would present with more symptoms perceived as AR. : This was a secondary analysis of a previous cross-sectional survey of 324 patients receiving manual therapy from Canadian physiotherapists. It included questions regarding symptoms patients experienced after a treatment including manual therapy and perceived as adverse. Poisson and negative binomial regression were used to determine factors associated with the number of symptoms that patients experienced and perceived as adverse. : Symptoms that affected patient's functionality were most often perceived as AR. The neck region was the body part with the greatest number of perceived AR (n = 83). Patients with neck pain who agreed that education may change their experience with AR had a lower incidence rate of AR. : Findings indicate that communication regarding post-treatment symptoms between clinicians and patients is important and can potentially influence patients' perception of post-treatment symptoms.
先前的定性研究表明,患者确定对手法治疗的反应是否不良的过程非常复杂。然而,仍然不清楚患者对手法治疗的哪些反应视为不良。
描述患者在接受手法治疗后经历和感知为不良反应的症状,并探讨身体部位不良反应(AR)发生率最高的预测因素。我们假设接受颈部疾病手法治疗的患者会出现更多被认为是不良反应的症状。
这是对加拿大物理治疗师为 324 名患者提供手法治疗的横断面调查的二次分析。它包括患者在接受治疗(包括手法治疗)后经历的症状以及感知为不良反应的问题。泊松和负二项回归用于确定与患者经历和感知为不良反应的症状数量相关的因素。
影响患者功能的症状最常被视为不良反应。颈部是感知不良反应发生率最高的身体部位(n=83)。颈部疼痛且同意教育可能改变他们对不良反应体验的患者,不良反应发生率较低。
研究结果表明,临床医生和患者之间就治疗后症状进行沟通非常重要,并且可能会影响患者对治疗后症状的感知。