Centre for Food Science and Nutrition, Addis Ababa University, P.O. Box 1176, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
School of Biosciences, University of Nottingham, Sutton Bonington, Leicestershire LE12 5RD, UK.
Sci Total Environ. 2020 Sep 1;733:139231. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.139231. Epub 2020 May 12.
Grain and soil were sampled across a large part of Amhara, Ethiopia in a study motivated by prior evidence of selenium (Se) deficiency in the Region's population. The grain samples (teff, Eragrostis tef, and wheat, Triticum aestivum) were analysed for concentration of Se and the soils were analysed for various properties, including Se concentration measured in different extractants. Predictive models for concentration of Se in the respective grains were developed, and the predicted values, along with observed concentrations in the two grains were represented by a multivariate linear mixed model in which selected covariates, derived from remote sensor observations and a digital elevation model, were included as fixed effects. In all modelling steps the selection of predictors was done using false discovery rate control, to avoid over-fitting, and using an α-investment procedure to maximize the statistical power to detect significant relationships by ordering the tests in a sequence based on scientific understanding of the underlying processes likely to control Se concentration in grain. Cross-validation indicated that uncertainties in the empirical best linear unbiased predictions of the Se concentration in both grains were well-characterized by the prediction error variances obtained from the model. The predictions were displayed as maps, and their uncertainty was characterized by computing the probability that the true concentration of Se in grain would be such that a standard serving would not provide the recommended daily allowance of Se. The spatial variation of grain Se was substantial, concentrations in wheat and teff differed but showed the same broad spatial pattern. Such information could be used to target effective interventions to address Se deficiency, and the general procedure used for mapping could be applied to other micronutrients and crops in similar settings.
在埃塞俄比亚阿姆哈拉地区的大部分地区进行了一项研究,采样了谷物和土壤,该研究的动机是先前有证据表明该地区的人口存在硒(Se)缺乏。对谷物样本(苔麸、画眉草和小麦)进行了硒浓度分析,对土壤进行了各种特性分析,包括不同提取剂中硒浓度的测量。为各谷物中硒浓度开发了预测模型,并使用多元线性混合模型表示预测值和两种谷物中的实测浓度,其中包括从遥感观测和数字高程模型得出的选定协变量作为固定效应。在所有建模步骤中,通过虚假发现率控制选择预测因子,以避免过度拟合,并使用α投资程序对测试进行排序,根据对可能控制谷物中硒浓度的潜在过程的科学理解进行排序,以最大限度地提高检测显著关系的统计能力。交叉验证表明,模型获得的预测误差方差很好地描述了两种谷物中硒浓度的经验最佳线性无偏预测的不确定性。预测结果以地图形式显示,并通过计算谷物中硒的真实浓度使得标准份量不能提供推荐的每日允许摄入量的概率来描述其不确定性。谷物硒的空间变化很大,小麦和苔麸中的浓度不同,但表现出相同的广泛空间模式。此类信息可用于针对硒缺乏症实施有效的干预措施,并且用于制图的一般程序可应用于类似环境中的其他微量营养素和作物。