School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, CA, United States.
Design for Health, IDEO, San Francisco, CA, United States.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2020 Jun 2;8(6):e15890. doi: 10.2196/15890.
Antenatal care (ANC) has the potential to improve maternal health, but it remains underutilized and unevenly implemented in many low- and middle-income countries. Increasingly, text messaging programs for pregnant women show evidence that they can improve the utilization of ANC during pregnancy; however, gaps remain regarding how implementation affects outcomes.
This study aimed to assess facilitators and barriers to implementation of an SMS text messaging intervention for pregnant women in Samoa and to assess its impact on ANC attendance.
This study took place in Upolu, Samoa, from March to August 2014 and employed a quasi-experimental design. Half (n=3) of the public antenatal clinics on the island offered adult pregnant women the SMS text messaging intervention, with 552 women registering for the messages. At the comparison clinics (n=3), 255 women registered and received usual care. The intervention consisted of unidirectional text messages containing health tips and appointment reminders. The outcome of interest was the number of attended antenatal visits. Implementation data were also collected through a survey of the participating midwives (n=7) and implementation notes. Data analysis included a comparison of women's baseline characteristics between the two groups, followed by the use of negative binomial regressions to test for associations between participation in the intervention and increased ANC attendance, controlling for individual characteristics and accounting for the clustering of women within clinics.
The comparison of ANC attendance rates found that women receiving the SMS text messaging intervention attended 15% fewer ANC visits than the comparison group (P=.004), controlling for individual characteristics and clustering. Data analysis of the implementation process suggests that barriers to successful implementation include women registering very late in pregnancy, sharing their phone with others, and inconsistent explanation of the intervention to women.
These results suggest that unidirectional text messages do not encourage, and might even discourage, ANC attendance in Samoa. Interpreted with other evidence in the literature, these results suggest that SMS text messaging interventions are more effective when they facilitate better communication between patients and health workers. This study is an important contribution to our understanding of when SMS text messaging interventions are and are not effective in improving maternal health care utilization.
产前护理(ANC)有改善产妇健康的潜力,但在许多低收入和中等收入国家,它的利用率仍然很低,且实施情况参差不齐。越来越多的针对孕妇的短信程序表明,它们可以改善怀孕期间 ANC 的利用率;然而,在实施如何影响结果方面仍存在差距。
本研究旨在评估萨摩亚孕妇短信干预措施的实施的促进因素和障碍,并评估其对 ANC 就诊率的影响。
本研究于 2014 年 3 月至 8 月在萨摩亚乌波卢岛进行,采用准实验设计。该岛一半(n=3)的公共产前诊所为成年孕妇提供短信干预措施,共有 552 名妇女登记接受短信。在对照诊所(n=3),有 255 名妇女登记并接受常规护理。干预措施包括包含健康提示和预约提醒的单向短信。感兴趣的结果是参加产前检查的次数。实施数据还通过对参与的助产士(n=7)进行调查和实施记录收集。数据分析包括对两组妇女基线特征进行比较,然后使用负二项回归检验参与干预与 ANC 就诊率增加之间的关联,控制个体特征并考虑到诊所内妇女的聚类。
对 ANC 就诊率的比较发现,接受短信干预的妇女比对照组少参加 15%的 ANC 就诊(P=.004),控制个体特征和聚类。对实施过程的数据分析表明,成功实施的障碍包括妇女在妊娠晚期才登记、与他人共享手机以及对妇女的干预解释不一致。
这些结果表明,单向短信在萨摩亚并没有鼓励,甚至可能阻碍 ANC 的就诊。结合文献中的其他证据,这些结果表明,当短信干预措施促进患者与卫生工作者之间更好的沟通时,它们更有效。本研究为我们理解短信干预措施在改善孕产妇保健利用方面何时有效和何时无效提供了重要贡献。