Université Caen Normandie, Normandie University, UNICAEN, Medical School, CHU de Caen, Caen, France.
Inserm U1086 Interdisciplinary Research Unit for Cancer Prevention and Treatment, Centre de Lutte Contre le Cancer, Centre François Baclesse, Caen, France.
Adv Nutr. 2020 Sep 1;11(5):1089-1101. doi: 10.1093/advances/nmaa062.
Caloric starvation, as well as various diets, has been proposed to increase the oxidative DNA damage induced by radiotherapy (RT). However, some diets could have dual effects, sometimes promoting cancer growth, whereas proposing caloric restriction may appear counterproductive during RT considering that the maintenance of weight is a major factor for the success of this therapy. A systematic review was performed via a PubMed search on RT and fasting, or caloric restriction, ketogenic diet (>75% of fat-derived energy intake), protein starvation, amino acid restriction, as well as the Warburg effect. Twenty-six eligible original articles (17 preclinical studies and 9 clinical noncontrolled studies on low-carbohydrate, high-fat diets popularized as ketogenic diets, representing a total of 77 patients) were included. Preclinical experiments suggest that a short period of fasting prior to radiation, and/or transient caloric restriction during treatment course, can increase tumor responsiveness. These regimens promote accumulation of oxidative lesions and insufficient repair, subsequently leading to cancer cell death. Due to their more flexible metabolism, healthy cells should be less sensitive, shifting their metabolism to support survival and repair. Interestingly, these regimens might stimulate an acute anticancer immune response, and may be of particular interest in tumors with high glucose uptake on positron emission tomography scan, a phenotype associated with poor survival and resistance to RT. Preclinical studies with ketogenic diets yielded more conflicting results, perhaps because cancer cells can sometimes metabolize fatty acids and/or ketone bodies. Randomized trials are awaited to specify the role of each strategy according to the clinical setting, although more stringent definitions of proposed diet, nutritional status, and consensual criteria for tumor response assessment are needed. In conclusion, dietary interventions during RT could be a simple and medically economical and inexpensive method that may deserve to be tested to improve efficiency of radiation.
热量限制以及各种饮食方案已被提出用于增加放疗(RT)诱导的氧化 DNA 损伤。然而,一些饮食方案可能具有双重作用,有时会促进癌症生长,而在 RT 期间提出热量限制可能会适得其反,因为维持体重是该疗法成功的主要因素。通过在 PubMed 上搜索 RT 与禁食或热量限制、生酮饮食(>75%的脂肪衍生能量摄入)、蛋白质饥饿、氨基酸限制以及沃伯格效应,进行了系统评价。共纳入 26 项符合条件的原始文章(17 项临床前研究和 9 项关于低碳水化合物、高脂肪饮食的临床非对照研究,这些研究被推广为生酮饮食,共代表 77 例患者)。临床前实验表明,在放疗前进行短暂禁食,和/或在治疗过程中进行短暂热量限制,可以增加肿瘤的反应性。这些方案促进氧化损伤的积累和修复不足,随后导致癌细胞死亡。由于它们具有更灵活的代谢,健康细胞的敏感性应较低,其代谢会转向支持生存和修复。有趣的是,这些方案可能会刺激急性抗癌免疫反应,对于在正电子发射断层扫描(PET)上摄取葡萄糖较高的肿瘤尤其有意义,这种表型与不良生存和 RT 抵抗相关。生酮饮食的临床前研究结果更具争议性,这也许是因为癌细胞有时可以代谢脂肪酸和/或酮体。目前正在等待随机试验来根据临床情况明确每种策略的作用,尽管需要更严格的饮食、营养状况和肿瘤反应评估的共识标准来定义这些方案。总之,RT 期间的饮食干预可能是一种简单、经济和廉价的方法,值得进一步研究以提高辐射效率。