Broadhurst M Jana, Dujari Shefali, Budvytiene Indre, Pinsky Benjamin A, Gold Carl A, Banaei Niaz
Department of Pathology, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California, USA.
Department of Neurology and Neurological Sciences, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California, USA.
J Clin Microbiol. 2020 Aug 24;58(9). doi: 10.1128/JCM.00311-20.
The impact of diagnostic stewardship and testing algorithms on the utilization and performance of the FilmArray meningitis/encephalitis (ME) panel has received limited investigation. We performed a retrospective single-center cohort study assessing all individuals with suspected ME between February 2017 and April 2019 for whom the ME panel was ordered. Testing was restricted to patients with cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pleocytosis. Positive ME panel results were confirmed before reporting through correlation with direct staining (Gram and calcofluor white) and CSF cryptococcal antigen or by repeat ME panel testing. Outcomes included the ME panel test utilization rate, negative predictive value of nonpleocytic CSF samples, test yield and false-positivity rate, and time to appropriate deescalation of acyclovir. Restricting testing to pleocytic CSF samples reduced ME panel utilization by 42.7% (263 versus 459 tests performed) and increased the test yield by 61.8% (18.6% versus 11.5% positivity rate; < 0.01) with the application of criteria. The negative predictive values of a normal CSF white blood cell (WBC) count for ME panel targets were 100% (195/195) for nonviral targets and 98.0% (192/196) overall. All pathogens detected in nonpleocytic CSF samples were herpesviruses. The application of a selective testing algorithm based on repeat testing of nonviral targets avoided 75% (3/4) of false-positive results without generating false-negative results. The introduction of the ME panel reduced the duration of acyclovir treatment from an average of 66 h (standard deviation [SD], 43 h) to 46 h (SD, 36 h) ( = 0.03). The implementation of the ME panel with restriction criteria and a selective testing algorithm for nonviral targets optimizes its utilization, yield, and accuracy.
诊断管理和检测算法对FilmArray脑膜炎/脑炎(ME)检测板的使用情况和性能的影响尚未得到充分研究。我们进行了一项回顾性单中心队列研究,评估了2017年2月至2019年4月期间所有疑似ME且已开具ME检测板检测医嘱的个体。检测仅限于脑脊液(CSF)有细胞增多的患者。在报告之前,通过与直接染色(革兰氏染色和荧光钙白染色)及CSF隐球菌抗原进行比对或重复ME检测板检测来确认ME检测板的阳性结果。观察指标包括ME检测板的检测使用率、非细胞增多性CSF样本的阴性预测值、检测阳性率和假阳性率,以及阿昔洛韦适当降阶梯治疗的时间。将检测限制在有细胞增多的CSF样本中,通过应用标准,ME检测板的使用率降低了42.7%(检测次数从459次降至263次),检测阳性率提高了61.8%(阳性率从11.5%提高到18.6%;P<0.01)。对于ME检测板的检测靶点,正常CSF白细胞(WBC)计数的阴性预测值对于非病毒靶点为100%(195/195),总体为98.0%(192/196)。在非细胞增多性CSF样本中检测到的所有病原体均为疱疹病毒。基于非病毒靶点重复检测的选择性检测算法的应用避免了75%(3/4)的假阳性结果,且未产生假阴性结果。ME检测板的引入使阿昔洛韦治疗时间从平均66小时(标准差[SD],43小时)缩短至46小时(SD,36小时)(P=0.03)。采用限制标准的ME检测板以及针对非病毒靶点的选择性检测算法可优化其使用、阳性率和准确性。