Kassardjian Vatche, Andiappan Manoharan, Creugers Nico H J, Bartlett David
Prosthodontics, Centre for Oral, Clinical and Translational Sciences, Guy's Hospital, London, UK.
King's College London, London, UK.
J Dent. 2020 Aug;99:103388. doi: 10.1016/j.jdent.2020.103388. Epub 2020 Jun 1.
The aim of this systematic review was to assess intervention rates of direct composite restorations in the worn dentition based on data published in clinical trials.
Searches of electronic data bases, grey Literature and hand searches were completed, and selection criteria were applied at the title, abstract and full paper stages. Unavailable full papers or papers with unsuitable data were excluded. A reference search was conducted, and a final set of papers were selected for data analysis. Data were extracted and noted as any intervention required or performed, or intervention free. Descriptive statistics were used to summarise the findings and the odds ratios were calculated.
1683 titles were found in the initial searches. On application of selection criteria, 140 abstracts were selected (Kappa 0.885), 17 papers were chosen by 3 reviewers (Kappa 0.914 - 0.942) and 12 selected for statistical analysis (Kappa 0.924). A total of 3540 composites in 386 participants were analysed, with 1919 in the anterior region, and 1044 in the posterior region of these 11.7 % required intervention. Annual Intervention Rates (AIR) ranged from 0.8 to 17.9% reflecting the variation in reporting.
There was wide variation between studies on the type of intervention. Overall the intervention rate of 11.6 % shows a favourable outcome but suggests some form intervention may be needed.
Direct composites remain a viable option to treat tooth wear but the outcome varies. Provided patients appreciate that some maintenance may be needed they are an effective intervention.
本系统评价旨在根据临床试验发表的数据,评估磨损牙列中直接复合树脂修复体的干预率。
完成了电子数据库、灰色文献和手工检索,并在标题、摘要和全文阶段应用了选择标准。排除无法获取的全文或数据不合适的论文。进行了参考文献检索,并选择了一组最终论文进行数据分析。提取数据并记录为任何需要或已进行的干预或无干预情况。使用描述性统计来总结研究结果并计算比值比。
在初始检索中找到1683个标题。应用选择标准后,选择了140篇摘要(卡帕值0.885),3名评审员选择了17篇论文(卡帕值0.914 - 0.942),12篇被选用于统计分析(卡帕值0.924)。共分析了386名参与者的3540颗复合树脂修复体,其中前牙区1919颗,后牙区1044颗,这些修复体中有11.7%需要干预。年度干预率(AIR)范围为0.8%至17.9%,反映了报告的差异。
不同研究在干预类型上存在很大差异。总体而言,11.6%的干预率显示出良好的结果,但表明可能需要某种形式的干预。
直接复合树脂仍然是治疗牙齿磨损的可行选择,但结果各不相同。只要患者认识到可能需要一些维护,它们就是一种有效的干预措施。