Shamsoddin Erfan
National Institute for Medical Research Development (NIMAD), Tehran, Iran.
Evid Based Dent. 2020 Jun;21(2):68-70. doi: 10.1038/s41432-020-0104-8.
Data sources This review included 13 clinical studies (observational or clinical trial) which reported results of studies of the 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV). The other 62 referenced papers were of different types (eg, reviews, WHO protocols, letter to editor etc).Study selection The study selected trials, reviews, and in-vitro research assessing the critical aspects of saliva as an easily accessible and early-stage diagnostic source, and also an entry route for 2019-nCoV. Most of the clinical studies were descriptive case series of patients who had contracted 2019-nCoV in China. These were mainly studies designed to compare saliva samples with throat swabs, with regard to the presence of 2019-nCoV RNA. Another aspect of the included studies was the susceptibility of oral tissues to 2019-nCoV due to the expression of angiotensin-converting enzyme II (ACE2) as a receptor for the 2019-nCoV. Some review studies and clinical infection control protocols were also included to discuss the transmission patterns of 2019-nCoV from the oral cavity. Studies were not restricted to English language and they were not all full-text papers.Data extraction and synthesis A narrative synthesis of the results was conducted using distinct headings and subheadings, defined by the authors based on relevancy to the consensus about the importance of saliva with reference to 2019-nCoV.Results There was an inherent heterogeneity among the included clinical studies concerning their designs, sampling techniques, and the results about the diagnostic value of saliva. The percentage of coronavirus disease of 2019 (COVID-19) patients with positive 2019-nCoV RNA varied from 12.9% to 91.67% among these studies. Regarding the possibility of direct virus invasion into the oral tissues, the results suggested that ACE2+ cells in salivary glands could possibly be the target cells of 2019-nCoV and theoretically could generate infectious saliva in a sustained way. Furin was suggested as another protein which makes the tongue more vulnerable to 2019-nCoV, especially in conditions inducing its upregulation (for example, squamous cell carcinoma). According to the comparisons between 2019-nCoV and SARS-CoV, saliva could be considered of diagnostic value via the early detection of viral RNA for both of the viruses. Whilst the viral peak was shown to be at onset of symptoms for 2019-nCoV, it can linger up to the tenth day after the appearance of symptoms for SARS-CoV. Finally, this paper warns about airborne transmission, particularly for close contacts.Conclusions Saliva can be proposed as an easily accessible diagnostic source although further clinical studies are required. Given the presence of viral RNA in saliva in the early stages of COVID-19, the recommendations to wear masks to prevent the rapid transmission of infectious droplets into the air, and keep a safe distance from other people are clearly based in evidence.
数据来源 本综述纳入了13项临床研究(观察性研究或临床试验),这些研究报告了2019新型冠状病毒(2019 - nCoV)的研究结果。另外62篇参考文献为不同类型(如综述、世界卫生组织协议、致编辑的信等)。
研究选择 该研究选取了评估唾液作为易于获取的早期诊断来源以及2019 - nCoV的传播途径等关键方面的试验、综述和体外研究。大多数临床研究是关于中国感染2019 - nCoV患者的描述性病例系列。这些主要是旨在比较唾液样本与咽拭子中2019 - nCoV RNA存在情况的研究。纳入研究的另一个方面是由于血管紧张素转换酶II(ACE2)作为2019 - nCoV的受体表达,口腔组织对2019 - nCoV的易感性。还纳入了一些综述研究和临床感染控制协议以讨论2019 - nCoV从口腔的传播模式。研究不限于英文,也并非都是全文论文。
数据提取与综合 作者根据与唾液对2019 - nCoV重要性的共识相关性,使用不同的标题和副标题对结果进行了叙述性综合。
结果 纳入的临床研究在设计、采样技术以及唾液诊断价值的结果方面存在内在异质性。在这些研究中,2019年冠状病毒病(COVID - 19)患者2019 - nCoV RNA阳性的百分比从12.9%到91.67%不等。关于病毒直接侵入口腔组织的可能性,结果表明唾液腺中的ACE2 +细胞可能是2019 - nCoV的靶细胞,理论上可能持续产生具有传染性的唾液。弗林蛋白酶被认为是另一种使舌头更易感染2019 - nCoV的蛋白质,尤其是在诱导其上调的情况下(例如鳞状细胞癌)。根据2019 - nCoV与严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒(SARS-CoV)的比较,通过早期检测病毒RNA,唾液对这两种病毒都可被认为具有诊断价值。虽然2019 - nCoV的病毒峰值出现在症状出现时,但SARS-CoV的病毒峰值在症状出现后可持续到第十天。最后,本文警告了空气传播,特别是对于密切接触者。
结论 尽管需要进一步的临床研究,但唾液可被提议作为一种易于获取的诊断来源。鉴于COVID - 19早期唾液中存在病毒RNA,建议佩戴口罩以防止感染性飞沫快速传播到空气中,并与他人保持安全距离显然是有依据的。