Bogosian Angeliki, Rixon Lorna, Hurt Catherine S
Division of Health Services Research and Management, City, University of London, London, UK.
Res Involv Engagem. 2020 Jun 24;6:35. doi: 10.1186/s40900-020-00212-7. eCollection 2020.
In 2014 Parkinson's UK conducted a research prioritisation exercise with stakeholders highlighting important clinical research questions. The exercise highlighted the need for effective interventions to be developed and tested to tackle a range of non-motor symptoms including: sleep quality, stress and anxiety, mild cognitive impairment, dementia and urinary problems. The present work set out to build on this exercise by prioritising types of non-pharmacological interventions to be tested to treat the identified non-motor symptoms.
A Patient and Public Involvement exercise was used to reach consensus on intervention priorities for the treatment of non-motor symptoms. A Delphi structure was used to support the feedback collected. A first-round prioritisation survey was conducted followed by a panel discussion. Nineteen panellists completed the first-round survey (9 people with Parkinson's and 10 professionals working in Parkinson's) and 16 participated in the panel discussion (8 people with Parkinson's and 8 professionals working in Parkinson's). A second-round prioritization survey was conducted after the panel discussion with 13 people with Parkinson's.
Physical activity, third wave cognitive therapies and cognitive training were rated as priority interventions for the treatment of a range of non-motor symptoms. There was broad agreement on intervention priorities between health care professionals and people with Parkinson's. A consensus was reached that research should focus on therapies which could be used to treat several different non-motor symptoms. In the context of increasing digitisation, the need for human interaction as an intervention component was highlighted.
Bringing together Parkinson's professionals and people with Parkinson's resulted in a final treatment priority list which should be both feasible to carry out in routine clinical practice and acceptable to both professionals and people with Parkinson's. The workshop further specified research priorities in Parkinson's disease based on the current evidence base, stakeholder preferences, and feasibility. Research should focus on developing and testing non-pharmacological treatments which could be effective across a range of symptoms but specifically focusing on tailored physical activity interventions, cognitive therapies and cognitive training.
2014年,英国帕金森病协会与利益相关者开展了一项研究优先级确定活动,突出了重要的临床研究问题。该活动强调需要开发和测试有效的干预措施,以应对一系列非运动症状,包括:睡眠质量、压力与焦虑、轻度认知障碍、痴呆症和泌尿系统问题。目前的工作旨在在此基础上,确定用于治疗已识别的非运动症状的非药物干预类型的优先级。
采用患者及公众参与活动就治疗非运动症状的干预优先级达成共识。使用德尔菲法结构来支持所收集的反馈。先进行第一轮优先级调查,随后进行小组讨论。19名小组成员完成了第一轮调查(9名帕金森病患者和10名从事帕金森病领域工作的专业人员),16人参加了小组讨论(8名帕金森病患者和8名从事帕金森病领域工作的专业人员)。小组讨论后,对13名帕金森病患者进行了第二轮优先级调查。
体育活动、第三波认知疗法和认知训练被评为治疗一系列非运动症状的优先干预措施。医疗保健专业人员和帕金森病患者在干预优先级上达成了广泛共识。达成的共识是,研究应侧重于可用于治疗多种不同非运动症状的疗法。在数字化程度不断提高的背景下,强调了人际互动作为干预组成部分的必要性。
帕金森病专业人员和帕金森病患者共同参与,得出了一份最终的治疗优先级清单,该清单在常规临床实践中应既可行,又为专业人员和帕金森病患者所接受。该研讨会根据当前的证据基础、利益相关者的偏好和可行性,进一步明确了帕金森病的研究优先级。研究应侧重于开发和测试非药物治疗方法,这些方法可能对一系列症状有效,但特别侧重于量身定制的体育活动干预、认知疗法和认知训练。