From the Translational Neuroradiology Section, National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke.
Radiology and Imaging Sciences, Clinical Center, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD.
Invest Radiol. 2020 Nov;55(11):727-735. doi: 10.1097/RLI.0000000000000698.
Cortical demyelination is common in multiple sclerosis (MS) and can be extensive. Cortical lesions contribute to disability independently from white matter lesions and may form via a distinct mechanism. However, current magnetic resonance imaging methods at 3 T are insensitive to cortical, and especially subpial cortical, lesions. Subpial lesions are well seen on T2*-weighted imaging at 7 T, but T2*-weighted methods on 3 T scanners are limited by poor lesion-to-cortex and cerebrospinal fluid-to-lesion contrast. We aimed to develop and evaluate a cerebrospinal fluid-suppressed, T2*-weighted sequence optimized for subpial cortical lesion visualization.
We developed a new magnetic resonance imaging sequence, inversion recovery susceptibility weighted imaging with enhanced T2 weighting (IR-SWIET; 0.8 mm × 0.8 mm in plane, 0.64 mm slice thickness with whole brain coverage, acquisition time ~5 minutes). We compared cortical lesion visualization independently on IR-SWIET (median signal from 4 acquisitions), magnetization-prepared 2 rapid acquisition gradient echoes (MP2RAGE), double inversion recovery (DIR), T2*-weighted segmented echo-planar imaging, and phase-sensitive inversion recovery images for 10 adults with MS. We also identified cortical lesions with a multicontrast reading of IR-SWIET (median of 2 acquisitions), MP2RAGE, and fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) images for each case. Lesions identified on 3 T images were verified on "gold standard" 7 T T2* and MP2RAGE images.
Cortical, and particularly subpial, lesions appeared much more conspicuous on IR-SWIET compared with other 3 T methods. A total of 101 true-positive subpial lesions were identified on IR-SWIET (average per-participant sensitivity vs 7 T, 29% ± 8%) versus 36 on MP2RAGE (5% ± 2%; comparison to IR-SWIET sensitivity, P = 0.07), 17 on FLAIR (2% ± 1%; P < 0.05), 28 on DIR (6% ± 2%; P < 0.05), 42 on T2*-weighted segmented echo-planar imaging (11% ± 5%; P < 0.05), and 13 on phase-sensitive inversion recovery (4% ± 2%; P < 0.05). When a combination of IR-SWIET, MP2RAGE, and FLAIR images was used, a total of 147 subpial lesions (30% ± 5%) were identified versus 83 (16% ± 3%, P < 0.01) on a combination of DIR, MP2RAGE, and FLAIR. More cases had at least 1 subpial lesion on IR-SWIET, and IR-SWIET improved cortical lesion subtyping accuracy and correlation with 7 T subpial lesion number.
Subpial lesions are better visualized on IR-SWIET compared with other 3 T methods. A 3 T protocol combining IR-SWIET with MP2RAGE, in which leukocortical lesions are well seen, improves cortical lesion visualization over existing approaches. Therefore, IR-SWIET may enable improved MS diagnostic specificity and a better understanding of the clinical implications of cortical demyelination.
皮质脱髓鞘在多发性硬化症(MS)中很常见,且可能广泛存在。皮质病变可独立于白质病变导致残疾,其可能通过一种独特的机制形成。然而,目前 3T 的磁共振成像方法对皮质,特别是皮质下病变,不敏感。7T 上的 T2*-加权成像能很好地显示皮质下病变,但 3T 扫描仪上的 T2*-加权方法受到病变与皮质、脑脊液与病变对比度差的限制。我们旨在开发和评估一种优化用于皮质下病变可视化的脑脊液抑制、T2*-加权序列。
我们开发了一种新的磁共振成像序列,反转恢复磁化率加权成像增强 T2 权重(IR-SWIET;0.8mm×0.8mm 平面,0.64mm 层厚,全脑覆盖,采集时间约 5 分钟)。我们在 10 名 MS 成人患者的独立 IR-SWIET(4 次采集的中位数信号)、磁化准备 2 快速获取梯度回波(MP2RAGE)、双反转恢复(DIR)、T2*-加权分段回波平面成像和相位敏感反转恢复图像上比较皮质病变的可视化。我们还为每个病例确定了使用多对比度阅读的 IR-SWIET(中位数为 2 次采集)、MP2RAGE 和液体衰减反转恢复(FLAIR)图像的皮质病变。在“金标准”7T T2*和 MP2RAGE 图像上验证了 3T 图像上的病变。
与其他 3T 方法相比,IR-SWIET 上皮质,特别是皮质下病变更明显。IR-SWIET 共识别出 101 个真正的皮质下病变(每个参与者的平均敏感性与 7T 相比,29%±8%),而 MP2RAGE 为 36 个(5%±2%;与 IR-SWIET 敏感性比较,P=0.07),FLAIR 为 17 个(2%±1%;P<0.05),DIR 为 28 个(6%±2%;P<0.05),T2*-加权分段回波平面成像为 42 个(11%±5%;P<0.05),相位敏感反转恢复为 13 个(4%±2%;P<0.05)。当使用 IR-SWIET、MP2RAGE 和 FLAIR 图像的组合时,共识别出 147 个皮质下病变(30%±5%),而 DIR、MP2RAGE 和 FLAIR 的组合为 83 个(16%±3%,P<0.01)。更多的病例在 IR-SWIET 上至少有 1 个皮质下病变,IR-SWIET 提高了皮质病变亚型的准确性,并与 7T 皮质下病变数量相关。
与其他 3T 方法相比,皮质下病变在 IR-SWIET 上显示得更好。3T 联合 IR-SWIET 和 MP2RAGE 的方案中,白质病变显示良好,改善了现有方法的皮质病变可视化效果。因此,IR-SWIET 可能会提高 MS 的诊断特异性,并更好地了解皮质脱髓鞘的临床意义。