Powers J L, Eckenrode J
Cornell University, Family Life Development Center, Ithaca, NY 14853.
Child Abuse Negl. 1988;12(2):189-99. doi: 10.1016/0145-2134(88)90027-0.
Official reports of maltreatment involving adolescent victims were compared to those involving younger children in a representative sample of protective services' reports drawn from New York State in 1985. Specific case characteristics, including age, gender, ethnicity of the victim, and source of report, are described and their relation to case substantiation is examined. Analyses revealed that adolescents represent a substantial proportion of all victims of official child maltreatment reports. The impact of age on substantiation varied as a function of the type of maltreatment, where for adolescents sexual abuse reports were more likely to be substantiated, while neglect and physical abuse reports were less likely to be substantiated. Reports involving adolescents were significantly more likely to involve a female victim. Significant gender differences in substantiation rate were found only for sexual abuse reports involving adolescents. White children were also found to be under-represented in this sample, while blacks were over-represented relative to their numbers in the population. The impact of minority status on substantiation was significant for neglect and physical abuse reports involving children. The majority of adolescent reports came from mandated sources, which had a significantly higher substantiation rate than reports from non-mandated sources.
在1985年从纽约州抽取的具有代表性的儿童保护服务报告样本中,对涉及青少年受害者的虐待官方报告与涉及年幼儿童的报告进行了比较。描述了具体的案件特征,包括受害者的年龄、性别、种族以及报告来源,并研究了它们与案件证实情况的关系。分析表明,青少年在官方儿童虐待报告的所有受害者中占相当大的比例。年龄对证实情况的影响因虐待类型而异,对于青少年而言,性虐待报告更有可能得到证实,而忽视和身体虐待报告得到证实的可能性较小。涉及青少年的报告更有可能涉及女性受害者。仅在涉及青少年的性虐待报告中发现了证实率的显著性别差异。在这个样本中还发现白人儿童的比例偏低,而黑人相对于其在人口中的数量比例偏高。少数族裔身份对涉及儿童的忽视和身体虐待报告的证实情况有显著影响。大多数青少年报告来自法定报告来源,这些报告的证实率明显高于非法定报告来源的报告。