Division of Epidemiology and Public Health, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK.
Addiction Research Group, Norwich Medical School, University of East Anglia, Norwich, UK.
Nicotine Tob Res. 2021 Feb 16;23(3):471-478. doi: 10.1093/ntr/ntaa126.
Finding effective ways to help pregnant women quit smoking and maintain long-term abstinence is a public health priority. Electronic cigarettes (ie, vaping) could be a suitable cessation tool in pregnancy for those who struggle to quit; however, healthcare professionals (HCP) must be informed about these devices to offer appropriate advice. This study used the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation, and Behavior (COM-B) model and Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) to explore HCP attitudes towards vaping in pregnancy and postpartum; beliefs about the health risks of vaping; perceived barriers and facilitators of vaping in pregnancy; knowledge of current guidelines and policies; and training needs.
Interviews (n = 60) were conducted with midwives (n = 17), health visitors (n = 10), general practitioners (n = 15) and stop smoking specialists (n = 18) across the United Kingdom. Interview transcriptions were analyzed thematically using the framework approach and the COM-B.
Discussing vaping as a tool for quitting smoking in pregnancy was prevented by a lack of capability (limited knowledge of vaping, lack of training in smoking cessation); lack of opportunity (restricted by organizational policies and guidelines, lack of time and financial issues impacting on training), and negative social influences (sensationalist media and stigma associated with vaping in pregnancy); and lack of motivation (fear of future litigation and comebacks should adverse effects from vaping arise).
Factors related to capability, opportunity, and motivation were identified that influence HCPs attitudes and behaviors towards vaping in pregnancy. Gaps in knowledge and training needs were identified, which could inform the development of targeted vaping training.
Vaping could be suitable in pregnancy for those struggling to quit smoking. However, HCPs must be informed about these devices to offer appropriate advice. These data extend our knowledge of factors influencing HCP attitudes and behaviors towards vaping in pregnancy. Generally, vaping was perceived as safer than cigarettes, but a perceived lack of evidence, health and safety risks, dependency, and regulation issues were concerning. Considering our findings, greater efforts are needed to ensure HCPs are sufficiently informed about vaping and guidelines available. More importance should be placed on training for all HCPs who have contact with pregnant women.
寻找帮助孕妇戒烟并保持长期戒烟的有效方法是公共卫生的重点。对于那些难以戒烟的孕妇来说,电子烟(即蒸气烟)可能是一种合适的戒烟工具;然而,医护人员必须了解这些设备,才能提供适当的建议。本研究使用能力、机会、动机和行为(COM-B)模型和理论领域框架(TDF)来探讨医护人员对怀孕期间使用蒸气烟的态度、对蒸气烟健康风险的看法、对怀孕期间使用蒸气烟的障碍和促进因素的看法、对当前指南和政策的了解以及培训需求。
对英国各地的助产士(n=17)、健康访视员(n=10)、全科医生(n=15)和戒烟专家(n=18)进行了 60 次访谈。使用框架方法和 COM-B 对访谈记录进行了主题分析。
由于缺乏能力(对蒸气烟的了解有限,缺乏戒烟方面的培训)、缺乏机会(受到组织政策和准则的限制,缺乏时间和财政问题影响培训)和消极的社会影响(耸人听闻的媒体报道和与怀孕期间使用蒸气烟相关的污名),以及缺乏动机(担心未来的诉讼和反弹,以防蒸气烟产生不良影响),阻碍了将蒸气烟作为怀孕期间戒烟的工具进行讨论。
确定了影响医护人员对怀孕期间使用蒸气烟的态度和行为的能力、机会和动机相关因素。发现了知识和培训需求方面的差距,这可以为有针对性的蒸气烟培训提供信息。
对于那些难以戒烟的孕妇来说,蒸气烟可能在怀孕期间是合适的。然而,医护人员必须了解这些设备,才能提供适当的建议。这些数据扩展了我们对影响医护人员对怀孕期间使用蒸气烟的态度和行为的因素的认识。总的来说,蒸气烟被认为比香烟更安全,但缺乏证据、健康和安全风险、依赖性和监管问题令人担忧。考虑到我们的发现,需要做出更大的努力,确保医护人员充分了解蒸气烟和现有的指南。应该更加重视对所有接触孕妇的医护人员进行培训。