Craig-Atkins Elizabeth, Jervis Ben, Cramp Lucy, Hammann Simon, Nederbragt Alexandra J, Nicholson Elizabeth, Taylor Allie Rae, Whelton Helen, Madgwick Richard
Department of Archaeology, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, United Kingdom.
School of History, Archaeology and Religion, Cardiff University, Cardiff, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2020 Jul 6;15(7):e0235005. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0235005. eCollection 2020.
Archaeology has yet to capitalise on the opportunities offered by bioarchaeological approaches to examine the impact of the 11th-century AD Norman Conquest of England. This study utilises an integrated multiproxy analytical approach to identify and explain changes and continuities in diet and foodways between the 10th and 13th centuries in the city of Oxford, UK. The integration of organic residue analysis of ceramics, carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotope analysis of human and animal bones, incremental analysis of δ13C and δ15N from human tooth dentine and palaeopathological analysis of human skeletal remains has revealed a broad pattern of increasing intensification and marketisation across various areas of economic practice, with a much lesser and more short-term impact of the Conquest on everyday lifestyles than is suggested by documentary sources. Nonetheless, isotope data indicate short-term periods of instability, particularly food insecurity, did impact individuals. Evidence of preferences for certain foodstuffs and cooking techniques documented among the elite classes were also observed among lower-status townspeople, suggesting that Anglo-Norman fashions could be adopted across the social spectrum. This study demonstrates the potential for future archaeological research to generate more nuanced understanding of the cultural impact of the Norman Conquest of England, while showcasing a method which can be used to elucidate the undocumented, everyday implications of other large-scale political events on non-elites.
考古学尚未充分利用生物考古学方法所提供的机会,来研究公元11世纪诺曼人对英格兰的征服所产生的影响。本研究采用综合多指标分析方法,以确定并解释英国牛津市在10世纪至13世纪期间饮食和饮食方式的变化与延续情况。对陶瓷的有机残留物分析、对人类和动物骨骼的碳(δ13C)和氮(δ15N)同位素分析、对人类牙齿牙本质中δ13C和δ15N的增量分析以及对人类骨骼遗骸的古病理学分析相结合,揭示了经济实践各个领域日益强化和市场化的广泛模式,与文献资料所表明的相比,征服对日常生活方式的影响要小得多且更具短期性。尽管如此,同位素数据表明不稳定的短期时期,尤其是粮食不安全状况,确实对个人产生了影响。在社会地位较低的城镇居民中也观察到了精英阶层对某些食品和烹饪技术偏好的证据,这表明盎格鲁 - 诺曼时尚可以在整个社会范围内被采用。本研究展示了未来考古研究对诺曼征服英格兰的文化影响产生更细致入微理解的潜力,同时展示了一种可用于阐明其他大规模政治事件对非精英群体未被记载的日常影响的方法。