Zhang Huixia, Wang Tao, Zhang Zhenxiang, Lin Beilei, Mei Yongxia, Zhang Yongchao, Chen Gang
The First Affiliated Hospital of Henan University of Chinese Medicine.
School of Nursing, Zhengzhou University.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2020 Jul 2;99(27):e20656. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000020656.
Stroke-related smartphone applications (apps) present enormous potential for stroke management as apps become increasingly prevalent in China. However, there is no comprehensive study reported about the currents status of stroke-related apps available to adopt in Chinese app market. The aim of this study is to assess the current status of stroke-related apps available to adopt in China.
Using Stroke-related keywords written in either Chinese or English, the top 6 most prevalent apps online stores in China were searched from June to August 2018, including android market, 360 app market, wan dou jia, baidu mobile app, ying yong bao, apple app store. The basic features of selected apps were analyzed based on operating system, cost, target people, engagement, online interaction, release date, size, popularity, and usefulness. The information accountability of selected apps was evaluated with the Silberg scale. The functionality of selected apps targeting stroke patients at home were reviewed by researchers.
Our study showed that the downloads of stroke-related apps from android platform and the engagement of health professionals in apps development were critically insufficient. And most apps didn't offer a platform to facilitate online interaction with health professional. The information accountability of apps also presented a huge room for improvement. The average Silberg score of 127 apps was 3.5 (out of 9) with most apps not disclosing sponsorship, authors' affiliations, credentials, and sources or references of information. Few apps were modified in the past months. What's more, although the apps targeting stroke patients at home have covered 9 functionalities, most apps had only a simple functionality.
This study identified areas for improvement concerning information accountability of stroke-related apps available for adoption in China and reviewed functionality of apps targeting stroke patients at home. The findings might guide the development for stroke-related apps in China in the future.
随着智能手机应用程序(应用)在中国越来越普及,与中风相关的应用在中风管理方面展现出巨大潜力。然而,目前尚无关于中国应用市场中可供采用的中风相关应用现状的全面研究报告。本研究旨在评估中国可供采用的中风相关应用的现状。
使用中文或英文书写的与中风相关的关键词,于2018年6月至8月搜索了中国6个最流行的在线应用商店,包括安卓市场、360应用市场、豌豆荚、百度手机助手、应用宝、苹果应用商店。基于操作系统、成本、目标人群、参与度、在线互动、发布日期、大小、受欢迎程度和实用性等方面,对所选应用的基本特征进行了分析。使用西尔伯格量表评估所选应用的信息问责制。研究人员对针对居家中风患者的所选应用的功能进行了审查。
我们的研究表明,安卓平台上与中风相关应用的下载量以及医疗专业人员在应用开发中的参与度严重不足。而且大多数应用没有提供便于与医疗专业人员进行在线互动的平台。应用的信息问责制也有很大的改进空间。127个应用的西尔伯格平均得分为3.5(满分9分),大多数应用未披露赞助情况、作者所属机构、资质以及信息来源或参考文献。过去几个月中很少有应用进行修改。此外,尽管针对居家中风患者的应用涵盖了9项功能,但大多数应用功能简单。
本研究确定了中国可供采用的中风相关应用在信息问责制方面有待改进的领域,并审查了针对居家中风患者的应用功能。这些发现可能会为未来中国中风相关应用的开发提供指导。