Bein Murad, Coker-Farrell Elizabeth Y
Department of Accounting and Finance, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Cyprus International University.
Department of Business Administration, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Cyprus International University.
Malawi Med J. 2020 Mar;32(1):37-44. doi: 10.4314/mmj.v32i1.8.
The report from the World Health Organization (WHO) reveals that health spending worldwide remains highly unequal as more than 80% of the world's population live in low and middle-income countries but only account for about 20% of global health expenditure. Another report by the WHO on the state of health financing in Africa published in 2013 intimates that countries that are part of their member states are still on the average level in meeting set goals in financing key health projects.
The study set out to investigate the association between public and private spending and health status for eight selected African countries, namely Burundi, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Kenya, Rwanda, Sudan, Tanzania and Uganda. Health status indicators include the incidence of tuberculosis, mortality rates, maternal deaths and prevalence of HIV.
Descriptive statistics and pairwise correlation are used to assess the relationship between healthcare spending and health status. Random and fixed effect models are further employed to provide insights into the association between descriptive statistics and pairwise correlation. We used annual data from the year 2000 to 2014 obtained from world development indicators.
The relationship between healthcare spending (public and private) and health status is statistically significant. Public healthcare expenditure has a higher association than private expenditure in reducing the mortality rate, tuberculosis and HIV for the average country in our sample. For example, an increase in public healthcare spending is negatively associated and statistically significant at 5% or better in reducing female mortality, male mortality, tuberculosis and HIV. Private healthcare spending is more impactful in the area of maternal deaths, where it is associated negatively and statistically significant at 1%. An increase in private healthcare spending is linked to a reduction in maternal deaths. We also compared the association between an increase in healthcare spending on males versus females and observed that public health expenditure impacts the health status of both sexes equally, however, private health expenditure provides a greater positive benefit to males. It is worth remembering that two goals of the United Nations agenda on sustainable development are gender equality and ensuring healthcare for all.
The findings of this research call for the selected African countries to pay more attention to public healthcare expenditure in order to improve health status, especially since private healthcare which provides access to healthcare facilities for some poor people leads to costs that are a burden. So, future research should focus on analyzing components of private healthcare spending such as direct household out-of-pocket spending, private insurance and direct service payments by private corporations as dependent variables to understand what form of private investment should be encouraged.
世界卫生组织(WHO)的报告显示,全球卫生支出仍高度不平等,因为世界上80%以上的人口生活在低收入和中等收入国家,但仅占全球卫生支出的约20%。WHO于2013年发布的另一篇关于非洲卫生筹资状况的报告暗示,其成员国中的国家在实现关键卫生项目筹资既定目标方面仍处于平均水平。
该研究旨在调查布隆迪、厄立特里亚、埃塞俄比亚、肯尼亚、卢旺达、苏丹、坦桑尼亚和乌干达这八个选定非洲国家的公共和私人支出与健康状况之间的关联。健康状况指标包括结核病发病率、死亡率、孕产妇死亡数和艾滋病毒感染率。
使用描述性统计和成对相关性来评估医疗保健支出与健康状况之间的关系。进一步采用随机效应模型和固定效应模型来深入了解描述性统计与成对相关性之间的关联。我们使用了从世界发展指标获得的2000年至2014年的年度数据。
医疗保健支出(公共和私人)与健康状况之间的关系具有统计学意义。在降低我们样本中平均国家的死亡率、结核病和艾滋病毒感染率方面,公共医疗保健支出的关联度高于私人支出。例如,公共医疗保健支出的增加与降低女性死亡率、男性死亡率、结核病和艾滋病毒感染率呈负相关,且在5%或更好的水平上具有统计学意义。私人医疗保健支出在孕产妇死亡领域影响更大,在该领域它与孕产妇死亡呈负相关,且在1%的水平上具有统计学意义。私人医疗保健支出的增加与孕产妇死亡数的减少相关。我们还比较了医疗保健支出增加对男性和女性的关联,发现公共卫生支出对男女健康状况的影响相同,然而,私人卫生支出对男性提供了更大的积极益处。值得记住的是,联合国可持续发展议程的两个目标是性别平等和确保全民医疗保健。
本研究结果呼吁选定的非洲国家更加关注公共医疗保健支出,以改善健康状况,特别是因为为一些贫困人口提供医疗保健服务的私人医疗保健会导致成为负担的成本。因此,未来的研究应侧重于分析私人医疗保健支出的组成部分,如家庭直接自付费用、私人保险和私人公司的直接服务支付作为因变量,以了解应鼓励何种形式的私人投资。