Department of Internal Medicine 1, University Hospital Frankfurt, Theodor-Stern-Kai 7, 60590, Frankfurt, Germany.
Department of Internal Medicine 1, Robert-Bosch-Hospital, Stuttgart, Germany.
J Clin Monit Comput. 2021 Oct;35(5):1085-1092. doi: 10.1007/s10877-020-00563-2. Epub 2020 Jul 30.
Standard monitoring of heart rate, blood pressure and arterial oxygen saturation during endoscopy is recommended by current guidelines on procedural sedation. A number of studies indicated a reduction of hypoxic (art. oxygenation < 90% for > 15 s) and severe hypoxic events (art. oxygenation < 85%) by additional use of capnography. Therefore, U.S. and the European guidelines comment that additional capnography monitoring can be considered in long or deep sedation. Integrated Pulmonary Index® (IPI) is an algorithm-based monitoring parameter that combines oxygenation measured by pulse oximetry (art. oxygenation, heart rate) and ventilation measured by capnography (respiratory rate, apnea > 10 s, partial pressure of end-tidal carbon dioxide [PetCO]). The aim of this paper was to analyze the value of IPI as parameter to monitor the respiratory status in patients receiving propofol sedation during PEG-procedure. Patients reporting for PEG-placement under sedation were randomized 1:1 in either standard monitoring group (SM) or capnography monitoring group including IPI (IM). Heart rate, blood pressure and arterial oxygen saturation were monitored in SM. In IM additional monitoring was performed measuring PetCO, respiratory rate and IPI. Capnography and IPI values were recorded for all patients but were only visible to the endoscopic team for the IM-group. IPI values range between 1 and 10 (10 = normal; 8-9 = within normal range; 7 = close to normal range, requires attention; 5-6 = requires attention and may require intervention; 3-4 = requires intervention; 1-2 requires immediate intervention). Results on capnography versus standard monitoring of the same study population was published previously. A total of 147 patients (74 in SM and 73 in IM) were included in the present study. Hypoxic events occurred in 62 patients (42%) and severe hypoxic events in 44 patients (29%), respectively. Baseline characteristics were equally distributed in both groups. IPI = 1, IPI < 7 as well as the parameters PetCO = 0 mmHg and apnea > 10 s had a high sensitivity for hypoxic and severe hypoxic events, respectively (IPI = 1: 81%/81% [hypoxic/severe hypoxic event], IPI < 7: 82%/88%, PetCO: 69%/68%, apnea > 10 s: 84%/84%). All four parameters had a low specificity for both hypoxic and severe hypoxic events (IPI = 1: 13%/12%, IPI < 7: 7%/7%, PetCO: 29%/27%, apnea > 10 s: 7%/7%). In multivariate analysis, only SM and PetCO = 0 mmHg were independent risk factors for hypoxia. IPI (IPI = 1 and IPI < 7) as well as the individual parameters PetCO = 0 mmHg and apnea > 10 s allow a fast and convenient conclusion on patients' respiratory status in a morbid patient population. Sensitivity is good for most parameters, but specificity is poor. In conclusion, IPI can be a useful metric to assess respiratory status during propofol-sedation in PEG-placement. However, IPI was not superior to PetCO and apnea > 10 s.
目前关于程序镇静的指南建议在进行内镜检查时常规监测心率、血压和动脉血氧饱和度。多项研究表明,通过使用呼气末二氧化碳监测(capnography),可以减少缺氧(动脉血氧饱和度 < 90% 持续 > 15s)和严重缺氧事件(动脉血氧饱和度 < 85%)的发生。因此,美国和欧洲的指南指出,在长时间或深度镇静时,可以考虑增加呼气末二氧化碳监测。
整合肺部指数(IPI)是一种基于算法的监测参数,它将脉搏血氧饱和度(动脉血氧饱和度、心率)测量的氧合作用与呼气末二氧化碳分压(PetCO)测量的通气(呼吸频率、呼吸暂停 > 10s)相结合。本文的目的是分析 IPI 作为监测接受异丙酚镇静的患者在 PEG 手术期间呼吸状态的参数的价值。
在镇静下接受 PEG 放置的患者被随机分为标准监测组(SM)或包括 IPI 的呼气末二氧化碳监测组(IM)。SM 组监测心率、血压和动脉血氧饱和度。在 IM 组,除了监测心率、血压和动脉血氧饱和度外,还进行了 PetCO、呼吸频率和 IPI 的监测。记录所有患者的呼气末二氧化碳和 IPI 值,但仅向 IM 组的内镜团队显示。
IPI 值范围为 1 到 10(10=正常;8-9=在正常范围内;7=接近正常范围,需要注意;5-6=需要注意,可能需要干预;3-4=需要干预;1-2=需要立即干预)。先前已经发表了关于同一研究人群的呼气末二氧化碳与标准监测的结果。
本研究共纳入 147 例患者(SM 组 74 例,IM 组 73 例)。62 例(42%)患者发生缺氧事件,44 例(29%)患者发生严重缺氧事件。两组患者的基线特征分布均衡。IPI=1、IPI<7 以及参数 PetCO=0mmHg 和呼吸暂停>10s 对缺氧和严重缺氧事件具有高敏感性(IPI=1:81%/81%[缺氧/严重缺氧事件],IPI<7:82%/88%,PetCO:69%/68%,呼吸暂停>10s:84%/84%)。所有四个参数对缺氧和严重缺氧事件的特异性均较低(IPI=1:13%/12%,IPI<7:7%/7%,PetCO:29%/27%,呼吸暂停>10s:7%/7%)。
多变量分析显示,仅 SM 和 PetCO=0mmHg 是缺氧的独立危险因素。IPI(IPI=1 和 IPI<7)以及单独的参数 PetCO=0mmHg 和呼吸暂停>10s 可以快速方便地得出患者在病态人群中的呼吸状态结论。大多数参数的敏感性都很好,但特异性较差。
综上所述,IPI 可作为评估 PEG 放置期间异丙酚镇静患者呼吸状态的有用指标。然而,IPI 并不优于 PetCO 和呼吸暂停>10s。