Department of Social Psychology and Quantitative Psychology, University of Barcelona, 08035 Barcelona, Spain.
Department of Applied Psychology, School of Psychology, University of Minho, 4710-057 Braga, Portugal.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Jul 31;17(15):5555. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17155555.
This systematic review offers a comprehensive examination of the relationship between leisure and self-esteem. The different perspectives were analyzed according to a framework that includes the different approaches for defining and measuring leisure, and a similar one was proposed for self-esteem. Articles indexed in the Web of Science (WoS) up to the end of 2018 were reviewed, specifically those that contained the keywords "leisure", "self-esteem" or "self esteem" anywhere in the manuscript. Articles that did not present the qualitative or quantitative instruments needed to evaluate leisure or self-esteem were excluded. A total of 49 articles included the final quantitative synthesis. The overall findings showed that the prevailing methodology was objective (external). As regards content, the following combinations predominated: the behavioral approach to leisure with the unidimensional approach to self-esteem and the experiential approach to leisure with the unidimensional approach to self-esteem. Less studies were observed with the combination of mixed approaches and more comprehensive analyses: the behavioral-experiential combined with the multidimensional. To conclude, this study shows there is a demand for further empirical studies that explore the relationships between leisure and self-esteem. It also identified which approaches are most desirable to expand our understanding of the relationships between leisure and self-esteem.
本系统评价全面考察了休闲与自尊之间的关系。根据包括休闲和自尊的不同定义和测量方法的框架分析了不同观点,并提出了一个类似的框架。综述了截至 2018 年底在 Web of Science(WoS)中索引的文章,具体来说,这些文章的手稿中都包含了“休闲”、“自尊”或“自尊”这三个关键词。排除了未提供评估休闲或自尊所需的定性或定量工具的文章。共有 49 篇文章纳入了最终的定量综合分析。总体结果表明,流行的方法是客观(外部)的。就内容而言,以下组合占主导地位:休闲的行为方法与自尊的单一维度方法以及休闲的体验方法与自尊的单一维度方法。观察到的组合采用混合方法和更全面分析的研究较少:行为-体验相结合与多维。总之,这项研究表明,需要进一步进行探索休闲和自尊之间关系的实证研究。它还确定了哪些方法最适合扩展我们对休闲和自尊之间关系的理解。