Ravier Gilles, Marcel-Millet Philemon
Laboratory C3S (EA 4660), Department of Sport and Performance, University of Franche-Comté, Besançon, France.
J Hum Kinet. 2020 Jul 21;73:115-124. doi: 10.2478/hukin-2019-0136. eCollection 2020 Jul.
To compare acute parasympathetic reactivation following usual training exercises, the acute post-exercise heart rate (HR) and heart rate variability (HRV) were analysed. Fourteen elite male handball players completed three separate sessions of 16-min small-sided games (SSGs), repeated sprints (RSs) consisting of two sets of six repetitions of a 25-m sprint with a 180° change of direction (12.5 m + 12.5 m) every 25 s and 40 min of handball-specific circuit training (CT, one brief action every 40 s). The HR was recorded during the exercises; HRV was assessed 10 min before and after exercise. The exercise HR was higher for SSGs than RSs and it was higher for RSs than CT. Comparison of the baseline and acute post-exercise HRV values showed that parasympathetic indices decreased following SSG (p < 0.01 - p < 0.0001; large effect size) and RS (p < 0.05 -p < 0.01; large effect size) interventions. For CT, recovery values remained similar to the baseline (small effect size). The comparison of the acute recovery period between exercise modalities showed that the root mean square of the successive differences (RMSSD) was lower for SSGs than RSs and CT. No difference in any HRV indices was observed between RSs and CT. Time-varying of RMSSD for successive 30 s segments during the 10 min recovery period showed lower values for SSGs than CT for all tested points; the progressive increase in the beat-to-beat interval was similar for all interventions. In conclusion, SSGs caused the greatest post-exercise vagal disruption and it is likely that CT is the exercise modality that least delays over-all recovery. These results might help coaches design better training sessions by understanding athletes' recovery status after completing their conditioning exercises.
为比较常规训练后的急性副交感神经再激活情况,分析了运动后的急性心率(HR)和心率变异性(HRV)。14名精英男性手球运动员完成了三个不同的训练环节:16分钟的小型比赛(SSG)、重复冲刺跑(RS),即两组,每组六次25米冲刺跑,每25秒进行180°转向(12.5米+12.5米),以及40分钟的手球专项循环训练(CT,每40秒进行一个简短动作)。运动过程中记录心率;运动前10分钟和运动后评估心率变异性。小型比赛的运动心率高于重复冲刺跑,重复冲刺跑的运动心率高于循环训练。基线和运动后急性心率变异性值的比较表明,小型比赛(p<0.01 - p<0.0001;大效应量)和重复冲刺跑(p<0.05 - p<0.01;大效应量)干预后副交感神经指标下降。对于循环训练,恢复值与基线相似(小效应量)。不同运动方式急性恢复期的比较表明,小型比赛的逐次差值均方根(RMSSD)低于重复冲刺跑和循环训练。重复冲刺跑和循环训练之间未观察到任何心率变异性指标的差异。在10分钟恢复期内连续30秒时间段的RMSSD随时间变化情况显示,所有测试点小型比赛的值均低于循环训练;所有干预措施的逐搏间期逐渐增加情况相似。总之,小型比赛导致运动后最大程度的迷走神经紊乱,循环训练可能是对整体恢复延迟最少的运动方式。这些结果可能有助于教练通过了解运动员完成体能训练后的恢复状况来设计更好的训练课程。