Chylinski Daphne, Rudzik Franziska, Coppieters T Wallant Dorothée, Grignard Martin, Vandeleene Nora, Van Egroo Maxime, Thiesse Laurie, Solbach Stig, Maquet Pierre, Phillips Christophe, Vandewalle Gilles, Cajochen Christian, Muto Vincenzo
GIGA-Cyclotron Research Centre-In Vivo Imaging, University of Liège, Allée du 6 Août 8 B30, B-4000 Sart-Tilman, 4000 Liège, Belgium.
Centre for Chronobiology, Psychiatric Hospital of the University of Basel, Willhelm Klein-Strasse 27, 4002 Basel, Switzerland.
Clocks Sleep. 2020 Sep;2(3):258-272. doi: 10.3390/clockssleep2030020. Epub 2020 Jul 16.
Arousals during sleep are transient accelerations of the EEG signal, considered to reflect sleep perturbations associated with poorer sleep quality. They are typically detected by visual inspection, which is time consuming, subjective, and prevents good comparability across scorers, studies and research centres. We developed a fully automatic algorithm which aims at detecting artefact and arousal events in whole-night EEG recordings, based on time-frequency analysis with adapted thresholds derived from individual data. We ran an automated detection of arousals over 35 sleep EEG recordings in healthy young and older individuals and compared it against human visual detection from two research centres with the aim to evaluate the algorithm performance. Comparison across human scorers revealed a high variability in the number of detected arousals, which was always lower than the number detected automatically. Despite indexing more events, automatic detection showed high agreement with human detection as reflected by its correlation with human raters and very good Cohen's kappa values. Finally, the sex of participants and sleep stage did not influence performance, while age may impact automatic detection, depending on the human rater considered as gold standard. We propose our freely available algorithm as a reliable and time-sparing alternative to visual detection of arousals.
睡眠中的觉醒是脑电图信号的短暂加速,被认为反映了与较差睡眠质量相关的睡眠干扰。它们通常通过目视检查来检测,这既耗时又主观,还妨碍了不同评分者、研究和研究中心之间的良好可比性。我们开发了一种全自动算法,旨在基于从个体数据得出的适配阈值进行时频分析,从而在整夜脑电图记录中检测伪迹和觉醒事件。我们对35名健康年轻人和老年人的睡眠脑电图记录进行了觉醒的自动检测,并将其与两个研究中心的人工目视检测结果进行比较,以评估该算法的性能。不同人工评分者之间的比较显示,检测到的觉醒数量存在很大差异,且人工检测到的数量始终低于自动检测到的数量。尽管自动检测到的事件更多,但通过与人工评分者的相关性以及非常好的科恩kappa值可以看出,自动检测与人工检测高度一致。最后,参与者的性别和睡眠阶段不影响性能,而年龄可能会影响自动检测,这取决于被视为金标准的人工评分者。我们建议将我们免费提供的算法作为一种可靠且节省时间的替代方法,用于觉醒的目视检测。