Turner Jonathan H, Schutt Russell K, Keshavan Matcheri S
University of California, Riverside, CA USA.
Department of Psychiatry and Clinical Research Scientist I, University of Massachusetts Boston and Lecturer, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA USA.
Am Sociol. 2020;51(4):470-505. doi: 10.1007/s12108-020-09448-y. Epub 2020 Jun 6.
In sociology's formative period between 1830 and 1930, evolutionary analysis organized much theorizing and research. This line of work ended abruptly in the 1920s but, over the last decades, has come back into the discipline somewhat piecemeal with the reintroduction of more sophisticated stage models of societal evolution, functional analysis, human ecological analysis, and other new lines of evolutionary inquiry outlined in this paper. Our goal is to demonstrate that revitalized paradigms of the past can still be useful with modest reconceptualization, while at the same time new intellectual movements in the other social sciences, especially economics and psychology, incorporating evolutionary ideas from biology provide sociology with an opportunity to develop that avoids the problems that let to the demise of this line of inquiry in the 1920s, as well as the problems of other social sciences applying their more narrowly focus models to sociological problems. Indeed, in developing more sophisticated theoretical and methodological approaches to incorporating biology and evolutionary analysis into the social sciences. When presented in a new, more sophisticated guise, old approaches like functionalism, stage models of societal evolution, and ecological models can be seen as still having a great deal of explanatory power, while revealing a progressive and future orientation that should appeal to all contemporary sociologists. It is time, then, for sociology to remember its past in order to move into the future.
在1830年至1930年社会学的形成时期,进化分析组织了大量的理论构建和研究工作。这项工作在20世纪20年代突然终止,但在过去几十年里,随着更复杂的社会进化阶段模型、功能分析、人类生态分析以及本文概述的其他新的进化研究方向的重新引入,它已有点零散地回归到该学科。我们的目标是表明,过去经过振兴的范式在经过适度的重新概念化后仍然有用,与此同时,其他社会科学,尤其是经济学和心理学中纳入生物学进化思想的新思潮,为社会学提供了一个发展机会,既能避免导致这一研究方向在20世纪20年代衰落的问题,也能避免其他社会科学将其更狭隘的聚焦模型应用于社会学问题时产生的问题。事实上,在将生物学和进化分析纳入社会科学以发展更复杂的理论和方法论方法方面。当以一种新的、更复杂的形式呈现时,诸如功能主义、社会进化阶段模型和生态模型等旧方法仍可被视为具有很大的解释力,同时展现出一种进步的和面向未来的取向,这应该会吸引所有当代社会学家。那么,现在是社会学回顾其过去以便迈向未来的时候了。