Zureick J L, Meltzer H Y
Department of Psychiatry, Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, OH 44106.
Biol Psychiatry. 1988 May;24(1):63-78. doi: 10.1016/0006-3223(88)90122-9.
Published studies of platelet monoamine oxidase (MAO) activity of paranoid (P) and nonparanoid (NP) schizophrenics and normal controls, and of hallucinating (H) and nonhallucinating (NH) schizophrenics and normal controls were critically reviewed, and summary analyses were conducted on the original published data. Methods of comparing results across studies are discussed. Meta-analysis of the results of 11 analyses from 9 studies, examining a total of 165 P and 152 NP schizophrenics and 985 normal controls, indicated that the typical P schizophrenic studied had platelet MAO activity lower than that of 61% of NP schizophrenics and 79% of normal controls. Meta-analysis of the results of 8 separate analyses from 6 studies comprising 130 H, 81 NH schizophrenics, and 186 normal controls indicated that the average H schizophrenic studied had platelet MAO activity lower than that of 84% of NH schizophrenics and 80% of normal controls. In comparison with normal control values, P schizophrenics had the greatest mean percentage decrease in platelet MAO activity (30%), followed by NP schizophrenics (24%), and H schizophrenics (24%). These findings could not readily be attributed to diagnostic, demographic, or methodological factors, nor to the effects of alcohol or neuroleptics.
对已发表的关于偏执型(P)和非偏执型(NP)精神分裂症患者及正常对照者,以及幻觉型(H)和非幻觉型(NH)精神分裂症患者及正常对照者的血小板单胺氧化酶(MAO)活性的研究进行了严格审查,并对原始发表数据进行了汇总分析。讨论了跨研究比较结果的方法。对9项研究中的11项分析结果进行荟萃分析,共检查了165例P型精神分裂症患者、152例NP型精神分裂症患者和985例正常对照者,结果表明,所研究的典型P型精神分裂症患者的血小板MAO活性低于61%的NP型精神分裂症患者和79%的正常对照者。对6项研究中的8项单独分析结果进行荟萃分析,这些研究包括130例H型精神分裂症患者、81例NH型精神分裂症患者和186例正常对照者,结果表明,所研究的平均H型精神分裂症患者的血小板MAO活性低于84%的NH型精神分裂症患者和80%的正常对照者。与正常对照值相比,P型精神分裂症患者的血小板MAO活性平均下降百分比最大(30%),其次是NP型精神分裂症患者(24%)和H型精神分裂症患者(24%)。这些发现不易归因于诊断、人口统计学或方法学因素,也不能归因于酒精或抗精神病药物的影响。