Annenberg School for Communication, University of Pennsylvania.
Department of Communication, Villanova University.
Health Commun. 2022 Jan;37(1):29-38. doi: 10.1080/10410236.2020.1816282. Epub 2020 Sep 8.
Media coverage can impact support for health policies and, ultimately, compliance with those policies. Prior research found consistent, high support for Tobacco 21 policies, which raise the minimum legal age of tobacco purchase to 21, among adults and nonsmoking youth. However, a recent study found support (i.e., agreement with the statement: "The legal age to buy tobacco cigarettes should be increased from 18 to 21") among 13-20-year-old smokers increased from 2014 until mid-2016 and then declined steadily through mid-2017. To assess whether media coverage could be related to young smokers' changing support, we conducted an exploratory content analysis to identify texts about Tobacco 21 in a large corpus of tobacco texts (N = 135,691) published in four popular media sources from 2014 to 2017. For this content analysis, we developed a novel methodological approach that combined supervised and unsupervised machine learning methods and could be useful in other areas of communication research. We found that the prevalence of Tobacco 21 media coverage and Tobacco 21 support among young smokers exhibited similar temporal patterns for much of the study period. These findings highlight the need for continued research into the effects of media coverage on Tobacco 21 support among young smokers, a group that must comply with Tobacco 21 policies in order to ensure maximum effectiveness. This research is of particular utility following the 2019 passage of a federal Tobacco 21 regulation, as the public health impact of this regulation could be limited by low public support, and thus low rates of policy compliance.
媒体报道会影响人们对卫生政策的支持程度,最终影响人们对这些政策的遵守程度。之前的研究发现,成年人和不吸烟的青少年普遍且高度支持将购买烟草制品的最低法定年龄提高到 21 岁的烟草 21 政策。然而,最近的一项研究发现,在 2014 年至 2016 年中期期间,13 至 20 岁的吸烟者对提高法定购买烟草年龄(“将购买烟草的法定年龄从 18 岁提高到 21 岁”)的支持率有所增加,之后在 2017 年中期开始稳步下降。为了评估媒体报道是否与年轻吸烟者支持率的变化有关,我们对一个大型烟草文本语料库(N=135691)进行了探索性内容分析,以确定 2014 年至 2017 年间四大流行媒体来源中有关烟草 21 的文本。在这个内容分析中,我们开发了一种新的方法学方法,结合了监督和非监督机器学习方法,这在其他传播研究领域可能会很有用。我们发现,在研究期间的大部分时间里,烟草 21 媒体报道的流行程度和年轻吸烟者对烟草 21 的支持率呈现出相似的时间模式。这些发现强调了需要继续研究媒体报道对年轻吸烟者对烟草 21 支持率的影响,因为这一群体必须遵守烟草 21 政策,以确保政策的最大有效性。在 2019 年联邦烟草 21 法规通过后,这项研究尤其具有实际意义,因为该法规的公共卫生影响可能会因公众支持率低而受到限制,从而导致政策合规率低。