González-Bustamante Bastián
Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Oxford, St Hilda's College, Cowley Place, Oxford OX4 1DY, United Kingdom.
Department of Public Administration and Policy, Universidad de Santiago de Chile, 3363 Lib. Bernardo O'Higgins Av., Faculty of Economics and Management Building, Santiago, Chile.
World Dev. 2021 Jan;137:105180. doi: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2020.105180. Epub 2020 Sep 4.
This article analyses the evolution of COVID-19 and early government responses to the pandemic in eight South American countries. To this aim, this study explores indicators which trace the progression of the pandemic and analyses factors related of state capacity which impacted on the early response of governments of implementing restrictive policies of social distancing associated with a suppression strategy. The pressure on the health systems is evaluated with early projections of the growth-phase of the epidemic, which is incorporated as an indicator in the analysis of early interventions based on Cox proportional hazards models. The results indicate that fiscal expenditure on health, regional and local government capacity, and pressure on the health system accelerate government response with stringent interventions. A counter-intuitive finding is that the economic strength of a country delays these types of reactions. The effect of these interventions is something that should be studied in greater depth, considering, for example, sociocultural factors. Lastly, only cases such as Uruguay and Paraguay show some signs of having the pandemic relatively under control by mid-May, while Brazil and Peru face very adverse scenarios. In this context, considering the characteristics of the states in the region and the level of informal employment, it will be a public policy challenge to keep the equilibrium between restrictive measures and the economic and social problems which these responses imply in the medium term.
本文分析了八个南美国家新冠疫情的演变以及政府对该疫情的早期应对措施。为此,本研究探索了追踪疫情发展的指标,并分析了与国家能力相关的因素,这些因素影响了各国政府实施与抑制策略相关的社会距离限制政策的早期应对。利用疫情增长阶段的早期预测来评估卫生系统的压力,该预测作为一个指标纳入基于Cox比例风险模型的早期干预分析中。结果表明,卫生方面的财政支出、地区和地方政府能力以及卫生系统的压力会促使政府采取严格干预措施加快应对。一个与直觉相悖的发现是,国家的经济实力会延迟这类反应。这些干预措施的效果值得更深入地研究,例如考虑社会文化因素。最后,只有乌拉圭和巴拉圭等国在5月中旬表现出疫情相对得到控制的迹象,而巴西和秘鲁则面临非常不利的局面。在此背景下,考虑到该地区各国的特点以及非正规就业水平,在中期内保持限制措施与这些应对措施所带来的经济和社会问题之间的平衡将是一项公共政策挑战。