Shibre Gebretsadik, Zegeye Betregiorgis, Ahinkorah Bright Opoku, Keetile Mpho, Yaya Sanni
Department of Reproductive, Family and Population Health, School of Public Health, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Shewarobit Field Office, HaSET Maternal and Child Health Research Program, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Arch Public Health. 2020 Sep 15;78:80. doi: 10.1186/s13690-020-00466-3. eCollection 2020.
Majority of maternal deaths are avoidable through quality obstetric care such as Cesarean Section (CS). However, in low-and middle-income countries, many women are still dying due to lack of obstetric services. Tanzania is one of the African countries where maternal mortality is high. However, there is paucity of evidence related to the magnitude and trends of disparities in CS utilization in the country. This study examined both the magnitude and trends in socio-economic and geographic inequalities in access to birth by CS.
Data were extracted from the Tanzania Demographic and Health Surveys (TDHSs) (1996-2015) and analyzed using the World Health Organization's (WHO) Health Equity Assessment Toolkit (HEAT) software. First, access to birth by CS was disaggregated by four equity stratifiers: wealth index, education, residence and region. Second, we measured the inequality through summary measures, namely Difference (D), Ratio (R), Slope Index of Inequality (SII) and Relative Index of Inequality (RII). A 95% confidence interval was constructed for point estimates to measure statistical significance.
The results showed variations in access to birth by CS across socioeconomic, urban-rural and regional subgroups in Tanzania from 1996 to 2015. Among the poorest subgroups, there was a 1.38 percentage points increase in CS coverage between 1996 and 2015 whereas approximately 11 percentage points increase was found among the richest subgroups within same period of time. The coverage of CS increased by nearly 1 percentage point, 3 percentage points and 9 percentage points among non-educated, those who had primary education and secondary or higher education, respectively over the last 19 years. The increase in coverage among rural residents was 2 percentage points and nearly 8 percentage points among urban residents over the last 19 years. Substantial disparity in CS coverage was recorded in all the studied surveys. For instance, in the most recent survey, pro-rich (RII = 15.55, 95% UI; 10.44, 20.66, SII = 15.8, 95% UI; 13.70, 17.91), pro-educated (RII = 13.71, 95% UI; 9.04, 18.38, SII = 16.04, 95% UI; 13.58, 18.49), pro-urban ( = 3.18, 95% UI; 2.36, 3.99), and subnational (D = 16.25, 95% UI; 10.02, 22.48) absolute and relative inequalities were observed.
The findings showed that over the last 19 years, women who were uneducated, poorest/poor, living in rural settings and from regions such as Zanzibar South, appeared to utilize CS services less in Tanzania. Therefore, such subpopulations need to be the central focus of policies and programmes implemmentation to improve CS services coverage and enhance equity-based CS services utilization.
通过剖宫产等高质量产科护理,大多数孕产妇死亡是可以避免的。然而,在低收入和中等收入国家,许多妇女仍因缺乏产科服务而死亡。坦桑尼亚是非洲孕产妇死亡率较高的国家之一。然而,该国剖宫产使用方面差距的程度和趋势相关证据匮乏。本研究调查了剖宫产分娩在社会经济和地理方面不平等的程度和趋势。
数据从坦桑尼亚人口与健康调查(TDHSs)(1996 - 2015年)中提取,并使用世界卫生组织(WHO)的健康公平评估工具包(HEAT)软件进行分析。首先,剖宫产分娩的可及性按四个公平分层因素进行分类:财富指数、教育程度、居住地和地区。其次,我们通过汇总指标来衡量不平等,即差异(D)、比率(R)、不平等斜率指数(SII)和不平等相对指数(RII)。为点估计构建95%置信区间以衡量统计显著性。
结果显示,1996年至2015年期间,坦桑尼亚社会经济、城乡和地区亚组在剖宫产分娩可及性方面存在差异。在最贫困亚组中,1996年至2015年期间剖宫产覆盖率增加了1.38个百分点,而同期最富有亚组中增加了约11个百分点。在过去19年中,未受过教育者、小学教育程度者和中学及以上教育程度者的剖宫产覆盖率分别增加了近1个百分点、3个百分点和9个百分点。过去19年中,农村居民的覆盖率增加了2个百分点,城市居民增加了近8个百分点。在所有研究调查中均记录到剖宫产覆盖率存在显著差异。例如,在最近一次调查中,观察到有利于富人的情况(RII = 15.55,95% UI;10.44,20.66,SII = 15.8,95% UI;13.70,17.91)、有利于受过教育者的情况(RII = 13.71,95% UI;9.04,18.38,SII = 16.04,95% UI;13.58,18.49)、有利于城市居民的情况( = 3.18,95% UI;2.36,3.99)以及国家以下层面的绝对和相对不平等(D = 16.25,9% UI;10.02,22.48)。
研究结果表明,在过去19年中,坦桑尼亚未受过教育、最贫困/贫困、居住在农村以及来自桑给巴尔南部等地区的妇女剖宫产服务使用率似乎较低。因此,此类亚人群应成为旨在提高剖宫产服务覆盖率和促进基于公平的剖宫产服务利用的政策和项目实施的核心关注点。