Njaka Stanley, Edeogu Oswald C, Oko Constance Chioma, Goni Mohammad Dauda, Nkadi Ndidi
Universiti Sains Malaysia Nursing Program, Malaysia.
Ebonyi State University Abakaliki, Nigeria.
Heliyon. 2020 Sep 14;6(9):e04800. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e04800. eCollection 2020 Sep.
WPV amongst healthcare workers has been reported as a public health challenge across the countries of the world, with more in the developing countries where condition of care and service is very poor.
We aimed to systematically produce empirical evidence on the WPV against health care workers in Africa through the review of relevant literature.
We sourced for evidence through the following databases: PubMed, Science direct and Scopus from 30 November to 31 December 2019 as well as the reference list of the studies included. A total of 22 peer reviewed articles were included in the review (8065 respondents). Quality appraisal of the included studies was assessed using critical appraisal tools for cross-sectional studies.
Across the studies, diverse but high prevalence of WPV ranging from 9% to 100% was reported with the highest in South Africa (54%-100%) and Egypt (59.7%-86.1%). The common types were verbal, physical, sexual harassment and psychological violence. The correlates of WPV reported were gender, age, shift duty, emergency unit, psychiatric unit, nursing, marital status and others. Various impacts were reported including psychological impacts and desire to quit nursing. Patients and their relatives, the coworkers and supervisors were the mostly reported perpetrators of violence. Doctors were mostly implicated in the sexual violence against nurses. Policy on violence and management strategies were non-existent across the studies.
High prevalence of WPV against healthcare workers exists in Africa but there is still paucity of research on the subject matter. However, urgent measures like policy formulation and others must be taken to address the WPV as to avert the impact on the healthcare system.
据报道,医护人员遭受工作场所暴力(WPV)是全球各国面临的一项公共卫生挑战,在护理和服务条件非常差的发展中国家情况更为严重。
我们旨在通过回顾相关文献,系统地提供关于非洲医护人员遭受WPV的实证证据。
我们于2019年11月30日至12月31日通过以下数据库获取证据:PubMed、科学Direct和Scopus,以及纳入研究的参考文献列表。本综述共纳入22篇经同行评审的文章(8065名受访者)。使用横断面研究的批判性评估工具对纳入研究进行质量评估。
在各项研究中,报告的WPV发生率各不相同但都很高,从9%到100%不等,南非(54%-100%)和埃及(59.7%-86.1%)的发生率最高。常见类型包括言语暴力、身体暴力、性骚扰和心理暴力。报告的WPV相关因素有性别、年龄、轮班、急诊科、精神科、护理工作、婚姻状况等。报告了各种影响,包括心理影响和辞职意愿。患者及其亲属、同事和上级是最常被报告的暴力实施者。医生大多涉及对护士的性暴力。各项研究中均不存在关于暴力的政策和管理策略。
非洲存在医护人员遭受WPV的高发生率,但关于这一主题的研究仍然匮乏。然而,必须采取政策制定等紧急措施来应对WPV,以避免对医疗系统产生影响。