Frahsa Institute of Sport Science, University of Tübingen, Wilhelmstr. 124, 72074 Tübingen.
Institute of Social and Preventive Medicine, University of Bern, Mittelstrasse 43, 3012 Bern, Switzerland.
Health Promot Int. 2021 Apr 15;36(2):493-504. doi: 10.1093/heapro/daaa076.
Health promotion research has increasingly called for transdisciplinary approaches. Such calls ask for bridging frameworks that define comprehensive sets of health determinants and appropriately conceptualize the roles of population groups as well as other relevant actor groups in the co-production of health. This article aims to present the seminal capability approach by Sen and Nussbaum as a potentially suitable framework for such bridging endeavors to guide health promotion research. It highlights domains of the capability approach that appear to be particularly relevant to bridging diverse disciplines and settings. Such domains particularly refer to the agency of decisive actor groups (population groups, professionals, policymakers and researchers) as well as to the differentiation of personal, social and environmental conversion factors that disciplines define within their specific epistemologies and ontologies. The article uses empirical examples from a German research consortium that aimed to promote physical activity in five different settings while fostering cooperation and conceptual alignment between several academic disciplines and sub-disciplines to highlight benefits and challenges of using the capability approach as a bridging framework for transdisciplinary health promotion. We conclude that the capability approach might serve as bridging framework to guide future transdisciplinary research if partners involved continuously exchange to develop a shared understanding of the issues to be researched.
健康促进研究越来越呼吁采用跨学科方法。这种呼吁需要建立桥梁框架,定义全面的健康决定因素,并适当概念化人群以及其他相关行动者群体在共同促进健康方面的作用。本文旨在介绍 Sen 和 Nussbaum 的开创性能力方法,作为指导健康促进研究的此类桥梁努力的潜在合适框架。它强调了能力方法中似乎特别与跨学科和跨环境相关的领域。这些领域特别涉及决定性行动者群体(人群、专业人员、政策制定者和研究人员)的能动性,以及学科在其特定认识论和本体论中定义的个人、社会和环境转换因素的差异化。本文使用了一个德国研究联盟的实证例子,该联盟旨在促进五个不同环境中的身体活动,同时促进几个学术学科和子学科之间的合作和概念协调,以突出使用能力方法作为跨学科健康促进的桥梁框架的好处和挑战。我们得出结论,如果相关合作伙伴不断交流以建立对要研究的问题的共同理解,那么能力方法可以作为指导未来跨学科研究的桥梁框架。