Koehlmoos Tracey Pérez, Janvrin Miranda Lynn, Korona-Bailey Jessica, Madsen Cathaleen, Sturdivant Rodney
Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, MD, United States.
Health Services Research Program, Henry M Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine, Bethesda, MD, United States.
J Med Internet Res. 2020 Oct 22;22(10):e23297. doi: 10.2196/23297.
With the continued spread of COVID-19 in the United States, identifying potential outbreaks before infected individuals cross the clinical threshold is key to allowing public health officials time to ensure local health care institutions are adequately prepared. In response to this need, researchers have developed participatory surveillance technologies that allow individuals to report emerging symptoms daily so that their data can be extrapolated and disseminated to local health care authorities.
This study uses a framework synthesis to evaluate existing self-reported symptom tracking programs in the United States for COVID-19 as an early-warning tool for probable clusters of infection. This in turn will inform decision makers and health care planners about these technologies and the usefulness of their information to aid in federal, state, and local efforts to mobilize effective current and future pandemic responses.
Programs were identified through keyword searches and snowball sampling, then screened for inclusion. A best fit framework was constructed for all programs that met the inclusion criteria by collating information collected from each into a table for easy comparison.
We screened 8 programs; 6 were included in our final framework synthesis. We identified multiple common data elements, including demographic information like race, age, gender, and affiliation (all were associated with universities, medical schools, or schools of public health). Dissimilarities included collection of data regarding smoking status, mental well-being, and suspected exposure to COVID-19.
Several programs currently exist that track COVID-19 symptoms from participants on a semiregular basis. Coordination between symptom tracking program research teams and local and state authorities is currently lacking, presenting an opportunity for collaboration to avoid duplication of efforts and more comprehensive knowledge dissemination.
随着新冠病毒病(COVID-19)在美国持续传播,在感染个体达到临床诊断标准之前识别潜在疫情爆发对于让公共卫生官员有时间确保当地医疗机构做好充分准备至关重要。为满足这一需求,研究人员开发了参与式监测技术,允许个人每日报告新出现的症状,以便对其数据进行推断并传播给当地卫生保健当局。
本研究使用框架综合法评估美国现有的针对COVID-19的自我报告症状追踪项目,将其作为可能感染聚集性病例的预警工具。这反过来将使决策者和卫生保健规划者了解这些技术及其信息的有用性,以协助联邦、州和地方努力调动有效的当前和未来大流行应对措施。
通过关键词搜索和滚雪球抽样确定项目,然后筛选纳入项目。通过将从每个符合纳入标准的项目收集的信息整理成表格以便于比较,为所有项目构建了一个最佳匹配框架。
我们筛选了8个项目;6个被纳入我们最终的框架综合分析。我们确定了多个共同的数据元素,包括种族、年龄、性别和所属机构等人口统计学信息(所有这些都与大学、医学院或公共卫生学院相关)。差异包括关于吸烟状况、心理健康和疑似接触COVID-19的数据收集。
目前存在几个项目,它们定期追踪参与者的COVID-19症状。目前症状追踪项目研究团队与地方和州当局之间缺乏协调,这为合作提供了机会,以避免工作重复并实现更全面的知识传播。