Kantarovich Diana, Vollbrecht Hanna B, Cruz Sebastian A, Castillo Hector, Lee Cody S, Kushner Josef, Leng Jim X, Morgan Vince K, Hellman Kevin M
Chicago Medical School, Rosalind Franklin University, North Chicago, IL, USA.
University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA.
J Med Educ Curric Dev. 2020 Sep 22;7:2382120520959691. doi: 10.1177/2382120520959691. eCollection 2020 Jan-Dec.
Wikipedia is commonly used to acquire information about various medical conditions such as chronic pain. Ideally, better online pain management content could reduce the burden of opioid use disorders. Our goal was to improve the quality of the content available on Wikipedia to make it more accurate and applicable to medical students and the general public while training medical students to practice evidence-based medicine and critically assess their sources of information.
An elective class in Neuroscience, Pain, and Opioids composed of 10 medical students met biweekly to discuss landmark and practice-changing research articles in the fields of acute pain, chronic pain, and opioid management. The professor chose Wikipedia articles relevant to this course. Three independent viewers analyzed the quality of citations, anecdotal medical content, and content value for both patients and medical professionals. As part of their coursework, students then edited the Wikipedia articles.
Although some of the Wikipedia pain topic content (6.7% ± 2.0) was anecdotal, financially biased, or inconsistent with Western Medical Practice content, overall articles included primarily high-quality citations (85.6% ± 3.1). On a 0-5 Likert scale, students felt content would be moderately helpful for both medical students/professionals (3.4 ± 0.2) and laypersons (3.5 ± 0.2). Editing and adding citations was feasible, but novel material was often reverted.
A significant amount of pain medicine content was relevant and amenable to student editing. Therefore, future use of this tactic could provide a unique opportunity to integrate evidence-based medicine into the medical curriculum and have a direct impact on the widely available medical information. Future refinement in the editorial process may also further improve online information.
维基百科常用于获取有关各种医疗状况(如慢性疼痛)的信息。理想情况下,更好的在线疼痛管理内容可以减轻阿片类药物使用障碍的负担。我们的目标是提高维基百科上可用内容的质量,使其更准确且适用于医学生和普通大众,同时培养医学生实践循证医学并批判性地评估其信息来源。
一个由10名医学生组成的神经科学、疼痛与阿片类药物选修课程每两周会面一次,讨论急性疼痛、慢性疼痛和阿片类药物管理领域具有里程碑意义且改变实践的研究文章。教授选择与本课程相关的维基百科文章。三名独立的审阅者分析了引用的质量、轶事性医学内容以及对患者和医学专业人员的内容价值。作为课程作业的一部分,学生随后编辑维基百科文章。
尽管维基百科上一些疼痛主题内容(6.7%±2.0)是轶事性的、存在经济偏见或与西方医学实践内容不一致,但总体文章主要包含高质量引用(85.6%±3.1)。在0至5的李克特量表上,学生认为内容对医学生/专业人员(3.4±0.2)和外行人(3.5±0.2)都有一定帮助。编辑和添加引用是可行的,但新内容经常被撤回。
大量疼痛医学内容相关且适合学生编辑。因此,未来采用这种策略可能提供一个将循证医学纳入医学课程的独特机会,并对广泛可用的医学信息产生直接影响。编辑过程的未来改进也可能进一步改善在线信息。