Sezer Atakan, Cicin İrfan, Karadeniz Çakmak Güldeniz, Özkan Gürdal Sibel, Başaran Gül, Oyan Başak, Eralp Yeşim, Güllüoğlu Bahadır M
SENATURK Senology Academy-Turkey, Istanbul, Turkey.
Department of General Surgery, Trakya University School of Medicine, Edirne, Turkey.
Turk J Surg. 2020 May 6;36(2):147-163. doi: 10.5578/turkjsurg.4815. eCollection 2020 Jun.
Cancer care is excessively influenced by the COVID-19 outbreak for various reasons. One of the major concerns is the tendency for delayed surgical treatment of breast cancer patients. The outbreak has urged clinicians to find alternative treatments until surgery is deemed to be feasible and safe. Here in this paper, we report the results of a consensus procedure which aimed to provide an expert opinion-led guideline for breast cancer management during the COVID-19 outbreak in Turkey.
We used the Delphi method with a 9-scale Likert scale on two rounds of voting from 51 experienced surgeons and medical oncologists who had the necessary skills and experience in breast cancer management. Voting was done electronically in which a questionnaire-formatted form was used.
Overall, 46 statements on 28 different case scenarios were voted. In the first round, 37 statements reached a consensus as either endorsement or rejection, nine were put into voting in the second round since they did not reach the necessary decision threshold. At the end of two rounds, for 14 cases scenarios, a statement was endorsed as a recommendation for each. Thirty-two statements for the remaining 14 were rejected.
There was a general consensus for administering neoadjuvant systemic therapy in patients with node-negative, small-size triple negative, HER2-positive and luminal A-like tumors until conditions are improved for due surgical treatment. Panelists also reached a consensus to extend the systemic treatment for patients with HER2-positive and luminal B-like tumors who had clinical complete response after neoadjuvant systemic therapy.
由于各种原因,癌症护理受到新冠疫情的过度影响。主要担忧之一是乳腺癌患者手术治疗延迟的趋势。疫情促使临床医生寻找替代治疗方法,直到手术被认为可行且安全。在本文中,我们报告了一项共识程序的结果,该程序旨在为土耳其新冠疫情期间的乳腺癌管理提供以专家意见为主导的指南。
我们采用德尔菲法,使用9级李克特量表,对51名在乳腺癌管理方面具备必要技能和经验的经验丰富的外科医生和医学肿瘤学家进行两轮投票。投票通过电子方式进行,使用问卷格式的表单。
总体而言,对28种不同病例情况的46条陈述进行了投票。在第一轮中,37条陈述达成了认可或拒绝的共识,9条由于未达到必要的决策阈值而在第二轮中进行投票。两轮结束时,对于14种病例情况,每条陈述都被认可为一项建议。其余14种情况的32条陈述被拒绝。
对于淋巴结阴性、小尺寸三阴性、HER2阳性和腔面A型肿瘤患者,在因手术治疗条件改善之前,普遍达成了给予新辅助全身治疗的共识。专家小组成员还达成共识,对新辅助全身治疗后达到临床完全缓解的HER2阳性和腔面B型肿瘤患者延长全身治疗。