Lancaster University, UK.
Lancaster University, UK.
Soc Sci Med. 2020 Nov;264:113403. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2020.113403. Epub 2020 Sep 28.
Obesity is a persistently newsworthy topic for the UK press and in recent years levels of coverage have increased. In this study, we examine the ways in which obesity has been framed by the press over a ten-year period (2008-2017), focussing both on areas of stability and change. The analysis is based on a ~36 million-word database of all UK newspaper articles mentioning the words 'obese' or 'obesity' published within this time frame and draws upon techniques from corpus linguistics - a collection of computational methods for examining recurrent linguistic patterns in large bodies of language data. Our analysis shows that, over time, obesity is represented increasingly as a biomedical problem that is both caused and should be prevented by individual action. Meanwhile, focus on wider environmental determinants of health, including the role of Government and the food industry, decreases over time. In the paper, we situate these trends within the wider context of UK society and argue that they both represent the increasing dominance of neoliberal models of health but also have the potential to contribute to weight stigma and the blaming of individuals. Accordingly, it is argued that the press should seek greater balance in its reporting of the potential causes of and solutions to obesity, as well as closer alignment with scientific evidence. By doing so, the press could begin to report on obesity in a way that raises useful public awareness around the topic and which challenges some of the stigma that currently attends to this social justice issue.
肥胖是英国媒体长期关注的话题,近年来报道的数量有所增加。在这项研究中,我们考察了媒体在十年间(2008-2017 年)对肥胖问题的报道方式,重点关注稳定和变化的方面。该分析基于一个约 3600 万词的英国报纸文章数据库,这些文章在这段时间内提到了“肥胖”或“肥胖症”这两个词,并借鉴了语料库语言学的技术——一种用于检查大量语言数据中重复出现的语言模式的计算方法。我们的分析表明,随着时间的推移,肥胖越来越被视为一种生物医学问题,它是由个人行为引起的,也应该通过个人行为来预防。与此同时,随着时间的推移,对健康的更广泛环境决定因素的关注,包括政府和食品行业的作用,逐渐减少。在本文中,我们将这些趋势置于英国社会的更广泛背景下,并认为它们既代表了新自由主义健康模式的日益主导地位,也有可能导致体重歧视和对个人的指责。因此,有人认为,媒体在报道肥胖的潜在原因和解决办法时,应该寻求更大的平衡,并更紧密地与科学证据保持一致。通过这样做,媒体可以开始以一种方式报道肥胖问题,这种方式可以提高公众对这一话题的认识,并挑战目前与这一社会正义问题相关的一些污名化。