Rakvaag Hilde, SØreide Gunn E, Meland Eivind, Kjome Reidun L
MPharm. Department of Global Public Health and Primary Care, Centre for Pharmacy, University of Bergen. Bergen (Norway).
Dr.Phil. Associate Professor. Department of Education, University of Bergen. Bergen (Norway).
Pharm Pract (Granada). 2020 Jul-Sep;18(3):2078. doi: 10.18549/PharmPract.2020.3.2078. Epub 2020 Sep 16.
Interprofessional collaboration between pharmacists and physicians in primary care has been linked to improved patient outcomes. How professionals position themselves and each other can shed light upon their relationship, and positioning theory can be used as a tool to better understand intergroup relations.
In this qualitative study, data were collected through six focus group interviews held between June and October 2019, three with pharmacists and three with physicians. The focus group interviews were conducted using a semi-structured interview guide. Data were audio recorded, transcribed verbatim, and analyzed using the Systematic text condensation method. Positioning theory was used as a theoretical framework to identify the positions assigned to community pharmacists by the pharmacists themselves and by the physicians.
Twelve pharmacists and ten physicians participated. The pharmacists positioned themselves as the "last line of defense", "bridge-builders", "outsiders" - with responsibility, but with a lack of information and authority - and "practical problem solvers". The physicians positioned pharmacists as "a useful checkpoint", "non-clinicians" and "unknown".
The study revealed both commonalities and disagreements in how community pharmacists position themselves and are positioned by general practitioners. Few of the positions assigned to pharmacists by the physicians support an active role for the pharmacists, while the pharmacists´ positioning of themselves is more diverse. The physicians´ positioning of pharmacists as an unknown group represents a major challenge for collaboration. Increasing the two professions´ knowledge of each other may help produce new positions that are more coordinated, and thus more supportive towards collaboration.
基层医疗中药剂师与医生之间的跨专业协作与改善患者治疗效果相关。专业人员如何定位自己以及彼此之间的定位能够揭示他们的关系,定位理论可作为一种工具来更好地理解群体间关系。
1)确定社区药剂师如何定位自己,以及他们如何被全科医生定位。2)评估这些定位的契合程度,这些定位与药剂师的积极定位如何一致,并讨论这些定位可能如何影响协作。
在这项定性研究中,通过2019年6月至10月期间进行的六次焦点小组访谈收集数据,其中三次访谈药剂师,三次访谈医生。焦点小组访谈使用半结构化访谈指南进行。数据进行了音频录制、逐字转录,并使用系统文本浓缩法进行分析。定位理论被用作理论框架,以确定药剂师自己以及医生赋予社区药剂师的定位。
12名药剂师和10名医生参与了研究。药剂师将自己定位为“最后一道防线”“桥梁搭建者”“局外人”(有责任,但缺乏信息和权威)以及“实际问题解决者”。医生将药剂师定位为“有用的检查点”“非临床医生”和“未知者”。
该研究揭示了社区药剂师如何定位自己以及如何被全科医生定位方面的共性和分歧。医生赋予药剂师的定位中,很少有支持药剂师发挥积极作用的,而药剂师对自己的定位则更加多样化。医生将药剂师定位为未知群体对协作构成了重大挑战。增加这两个专业对彼此的了解可能有助于产生更协调、从而更支持协作的新定位。