Falcó-Pegueroles Anna, Rodríguez-Martín Dolors, Ramos-Pozón Sergio, Zuriguel-Pérez Esperanza
Department of Fundamental Care and Medical Surgital Nursing, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, School of Nursing, Consolidated Research Group Quantitative Psychology (2017-SGR-269), University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
Department of Fundamental Care and Medical Surgital Nursing, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, School of Nursing, Consolidated Research Group on Gender, Identity and Diversity (2017-SGR-1091), University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
Nurs Philos. 2021 Jan;22(1):e12332. doi: 10.1111/nup.12332. Epub 2020 Oct 7.
Critical thinking is a complex, dynamic process formed by attitudes and strategic skills, with the aim of achieving a specific goal or objective. The attitudes, including the critical thinking attitudes, constitute an important part of the idea of good care, of the good professional. It could be said that they become a virtue of the nursing profession. In this context, the ethics of virtue is a theoretical framework that becomes essential for analyse the critical thinking concept in nursing care and nursing science. Because the ethics of virtue consider how cultivating virtues are necessary to understand and justify the decisions and guide the actions. Based on selective analysis of the descriptive and empirical literature that addresses conceptual review of critical thinking, we conducted an analysis of this topic in the settings of clinical practice, training and research from the virtue ethical framework. Following JBI critical appraisal checklist for text and opinion papers, we argue the need for critical thinking as an essential element for true excellence in care and that it should be encouraged among professionals. The importance of developing critical thinking skills in education is well substantiated; however, greater efforts are required to implement educational strategies directed at developing critical thinking in students and professionals undergoing training, along with measures that demonstrate their success. Lastly, we show that critical thinking constitutes a fundamental component in the research process, and can improve research competencies in nursing. We conclude that future research and actions must go further in the search for new evidence and open new horizons, to ensure a positive effect on clinical practice, patient health, student education and the growth of nursing science.
批判性思维是一个由态度和策略性技能构成的复杂、动态的过程,旨在实现特定的目标。这些态度,包括批判性思维态度,构成了优质护理理念以及优秀专业人员理念的重要组成部分。可以说,它们成为了护理专业的一种美德。在这种背景下,美德伦理学是一个理论框架,对于分析护理实践和护理科学中的批判性思维概念至关重要。因为美德伦理学考虑了培养美德对于理解和证明决策以及指导行动的必要性。基于对涉及批判性思维概念性综述的描述性和实证文献的选择性分析,我们从美德伦理框架的角度,在临床实践、培训和研究环境中对该主题进行了分析。遵循JBI文本和观点论文的批判性评价清单,我们认为批判性思维是实现真正卓越护理的关键要素,应在专业人员中予以鼓励。在教育中培养批判性思维技能的重要性已得到充分证实;然而,需要做出更大努力来实施旨在培养学生和接受培训的专业人员批判性思维的教育策略,以及展示这些策略成功的措施。最后,我们表明批判性思维是研究过程的一个基本组成部分,并且可以提高护理研究能力。我们得出结论,未来的研究和行动必须在寻找新证据和开拓新视野方面更进一步,以确保对临床实践、患者健康、学生教育和护理科学的发展产生积极影响。