Kagevi I, Anker-Hansen O, Carling L, Glise H, Hallerbäck B, Solhaug J H, Svedberg L E, Wählby L
Scand J Gastroenterol Suppl. 1987;127:67-76. doi: 10.3109/00365528709090954.
A double-blind, randomized, multicenter study was performed to compare the effects of sucralfate and cimetidine for the short-term treatment of gastric and prepyloric ulcers. Ulcer healing was evaluated endoscopically at 4-week intervals up to 8 weeks in the PPU study and up to 12 weeks in the GU study. A total of 142 PPU and 134 GU patients completed the study. The overall healing rates after 8 weeks in the PPU study were 83% for the sucralfate group and 90% for the cimetidine group (NS), while the cumulative healing rates after 12 weeks in the GU study were 98% for the sucralfate group and 94% for the cimetidine group (NS). The confidence interval means that the 95% confidence limit ranges from 11% in favour of sucralfate to 2% in favour of cimetidine in the GU study and corresponding figures of 4% 19% in the PPU study. There were significantly more patients in the cimetidine group taking antacid tablets after 3 weeks in the GU study. Symptomatic relief did not differ significantly. Reported side effects and symptoms, pooled together with our duodenal ulcer study, were mostly non-specific and in some part related to the ulcer disease. In conclusion, sucralfate and cimetidine are both excellent healing agents for the short-term treatment of PPU and GU. Both give rapid and good symptomatic relief with no side effects of any importance.
开展了一项双盲、随机、多中心研究,以比较硫糖铝和西咪替丁对胃和幽门管溃疡短期治疗的效果。在幽门管溃疡(PPU)研究中,每隔4周通过内镜评估溃疡愈合情况,直至8周;在胃溃疡(GU)研究中,直至12周。共有142例PPU患者和134例GU患者完成了研究。在PPU研究中,8周后硫糖铝组的总体愈合率为83%,西咪替丁组为90%(无显著差异);而在GU研究中,12周后硫糖铝组的累积愈合率为98%,西咪替丁组为94%(无显著差异)。置信区间意味着,在GU研究中,95%置信限度的范围是有利于硫糖铝的11%至有利于西咪替丁的2%;在PPU研究中,相应数字为4%至19%。在GU研究中,3周后西咪替丁组服用抗酸片的患者明显更多。症状缓解情况无显著差异。汇总我们的十二指肠溃疡研究后报告的副作用和症状大多不具有特异性,且部分与溃疡病有关。总之,硫糖铝和西咪替丁都是短期治疗PPU和GU的优秀愈合剂。两者都能迅速且良好地缓解症状,且无任何重要的副作用。