Escola Superior de Educação Física, Universidade Federal de Pelotas, Pelotas, Brasil.
Eur J Sport Sci. 2021 Sep;21(9):1306-1313. doi: 10.1080/17461391.2020.1833087. Epub 2020 Oct 27.
Studies involving the manipulation of instructions regarding the negative characteristics of a group or comparisons with members of another group (explicit activation of stereotypes) have shown that age, weight, and gender stereotypes can be harmful to motor performance and learning. To date, however, no study has observed whether implicit stereotype threats, such as the sex of the coach or experimenter, can also influence the acquisition of motor skills. In the present study, the individual and combined impact of implicit and explicit influences of gender stereotype on women's soccer performance and learning was examined. In a 2 × 2 design, 60 women were divided into four groups according to the presence or absence of explicit (ES) and implicit (IS) stereotypes: ES/IS, ES, IS, and control. The groups with implicit activation practiced in the presence of a male experimenter. The groups with explicit activation received instructions activating the gender negative stereotype. The control group practiced without stereotype activations. The results showed that both explicit and implicit activation additively impaired soccer performance and learning, with both main effects being significant for practice and retention. The ES/IS group showed lower scores on the task relative to the other groups, while the ES and IS groups showed worse scores compared with the control group. The findings suggest that stigmatised populations may be forced to cope with more than one social identity threat while learning sport motor skills and indicate the importance of further studies testing strategies to minimise the deleterious effects of negative stereotypes.
研究表明,涉及操纵群体负面特征的指令或与另一群体成员进行比较的研究(明确激活刻板印象)表明,年龄、体重和性别刻板印象可能会对运动表现和学习产生有害影响。然而,迄今为止,尚无研究观察到隐含的刻板印象威胁(例如教练或实验者的性别)是否也会影响运动技能的获得。在本研究中,我们考察了性别刻板印象的隐含和显性影响对女子足球表现和学习的个体和综合影响。在 2×2 的设计中,根据是否存在显性(ES)和隐含(IS)刻板印象,将 60 名女性分为四组:ES/IS、ES、IS 和对照组。具有隐含激活的组在男性实验者的存在下进行练习。具有显性激活的组收到了激活性别负面刻板印象的指令。对照组在没有刻板印象激活的情况下进行练习。结果表明,显性和隐含的激活都对足球表现和学习产生了累加性的损害,练习和保持两个主要效果都具有显著性。ES/IS 组在任务中的得分相对低于其他组,而 ES 和 IS 组的得分则明显低于对照组。这些发现表明,被污名化的人群在学习运动技能时可能被迫应对不止一种社会身份威胁,并表明进一步研究测试策略以最小化负面刻板印象的有害影响的重要性。