Dutch Institution of Applied Science, TNO, Department Risk Analysis (RAPID) - Team Exposure Assessment and Risk Management, CB Utrecht, Netherlands.
Ann Work Expo Health. 2021 Jan 14;65(1):3-10. doi: 10.1093/annweh/wxaa093.
Will sensor-based exposure assessment be the future in workplace settings? Static instruments with embedded sensors are already applied to monitor levels of dangerous substances-in the context of acute health effects-at critical locations. However, with wearable, lightweight, miniaturized (low-cost) sensors developing quickly, much more is possible with sensors in relation to exposure assessment. Sensors can be applied in the work environment, on machines, or on employees and may include sensors that measure chemical exposures, but also sensors or other technologies that collect contextual information to support the exposure measurements. Like every technology it also has downsides. Sensors collect data on individuals that, depending on the purpose, need to be shared with others (e.g. health, safety and environment manager). One can imagine that people are afraid of misuse. To explore possible ethical and privacy issues that may come along with the introduction of sensors in the workplace, we organized a workshop with stakeholders (n = 32) to discuss three possible sensor-based scenarios in a structured way around five themes: purpose, efficacy, intrusiveness, proportionality, and fairness. The main conclusion of the discussions was that stakeholders currently see benefits in using sensors for applied targeted studies (short periods, clear reasons). In order to find acceptance for the implementation of sensors, all individuals affected by the sensors or its data need to be involved in the decisions on the purpose and application of sensors. Possible negative side effects need to be discussed and addressed. Continuous sensor-based monitoring of workers currently appears to be a bridge too far for the participants of this workshop.
基于传感器的暴露评估将成为未来的工作场所设置吗?带有嵌入式传感器的静态仪器已经被应用于监测危险物质的水平——在急性健康影响的背景下——在关键位置。然而,随着可穿戴、轻便、微型化(低成本)传感器的快速发展,传感器在暴露评估方面可能会有更多的应用。传感器可以应用于工作环境、机器或员工身上,并且可能包括测量化学暴露的传感器,但也可能包括收集上下文信息以支持暴露测量的传感器或其他技术。像每一项技术一样,它也有缺点。传感器会收集个人的数据,这些数据根据目的需要与他人共享(例如健康、安全和环境经理)。人们可以想象,人们担心被滥用。为了探讨在工作场所引入传感器可能带来的伦理和隐私问题,我们组织了一次利益相关者研讨会(n=32),围绕五个主题以结构化的方式讨论了三种基于传感器的可能情况:目的、功效、侵扰性、相称性和公平性。讨论的主要结论是,利益相关者目前认为在应用针对性研究中使用传感器是有益的(短期、明确的原因)。为了使传感器的实施得到认可,所有受传感器或其数据影响的个人都需要参与关于传感器的目的和应用的决策。需要讨论和解决可能的负面副作用。连续的基于传感器的工人监测目前似乎对研讨会的参与者来说是一个过于遥远的目标。