Faculty of Medicine, Johannes-Kepler Universität, Linz, Austria.
Department of Neurology 1, Kepler Universitätsklinikum, Linz, Austria.
Eur J Neurol. 2021 Jan;28(1):7-14. doi: 10.1111/ene.14521. Epub 2020 Oct 15.
The recent SARS-CoV-2 pandemic has posed multiple challenges to the practice of clinical neurology including recognition of emerging neurological complications and management of coexistent neurological diseases. In a fast-evolving pandemic, evidence-based studies are lacking in many areas. This paper presents European Academy of Neurology (EAN) expert consensus statements to guide neurologists caring for patients with COVID-19.
A refined Delphi methodology was applied. In round 1, statements were provided by EAN scientific panels (SPs). In round 2, these statements were circulated to SP members not involved in writing them, asking for agreement/disagreement. Items with agreement >70% were retained for round 3, in which SP co-chairs rated importance on a five-point Likert scale. Results were graded by importance and reported as consensus statements.
In round one, 70 statements were provided by 23 SPs. In round two, 259/1061 SP member responses were received. Fifty-nine statements obtained >70% agreement and were retained. In round three, responses were received from 55 co-chairs of 29 SPs. Whilst general recommendations related to prevention of COVID-19 transmission had high levels of agreement and importance, opinion was more varied concerning statements related to therapy.
This is the first structured consensus statement on good clinical practice in patients with neurological disease during the COVID-19 pandemic that provides immediate guidance for neurologists. In this fast-evolving pandemic, a rapid response using refined Delphi methodology is possible, but guidance may be subject to change as further evidence emerges.
最近的 SARS-CoV-2 大流行对临床神经病学的实践提出了多重挑战,包括对新出现的神经系统并发症的识别和共存神经系统疾病的处理。在快速演变的大流行中,许多领域都缺乏基于证据的研究。本文提出了欧洲神经病学学会(EAN)的专家共识声明,以指导照顾 COVID-19 患者的神经科医生。
采用了改进的 Delphi 方法。在第一轮中,EAN 科学小组(SP)提供了声明。在第二轮中,这些声明分发给未参与编写的 SP 成员,要求他们表示同意/不同意。获得>70%同意的项目保留用于第三轮,其中 SP 联合主席按五点李克特量表对重要性进行评分。结果按重要性分级,并作为共识声明报告。
在第一轮中,23 个 SP 提供了 70 个声明。在第二轮中,收到了 1061 个 SP 成员中的 259 个回复。获得>70%同意的 59 个声明被保留。在第三轮中,来自 29 个 SP 的 55 个联合主席收到了回复。虽然与预防 COVID-19 传播有关的一般建议得到了高度的一致和重视,但与治疗有关的声明的意见则更为多样化。
这是在 COVID-19 大流行期间针对患有神经疾病的患者制定的第一个关于良好临床实践的结构化共识声明,为神经科医生提供了即时指导。在这种快速演变的大流行中,使用改进的 Delphi 方法可以快速做出反应,但随着更多证据的出现,指导可能会发生变化。