School of Health, Medical and Applied Sciences, CQUniversity, Rockhampton, Queensland, Australia.
School of Health, Medical and Applied Sciences, CQUniversity, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2020 Dec;29(6):1035-1048. doi: 10.1111/inm.12794. Epub 2020 Oct 16.
Recovery-oriented practice has become the dominant paradigm of practice in mental health services internationally. The exception is hospital-based mental health services where the biomedical model continues to prevail, in this context defined by high acuity and safety concerns. This review aims to identify the approaches to, and feasibility of, implementing recovery-oriented practice in hospital-based mental health services. A systematic review of the literature (2010-2019) identified seventeen studies of recovery-oriented practice implementation in hospital-based mental health services. One study was excluded based on quality assessment. Of the remaining studies, seven reported on staff training initiatives, four reported service user programmes facilitated by staff, and five were implementations of models of care. The findings indicate that it is feasible, albeit challenging, to implement recovery-oriented practice in hospital-based mental health services. More successful approaches are multimodal, applied over several years and have organizational support. The main barriers to implementation include resistance to change from the embedded, biomedical model, staff attitudes towards recovery, and an absence of consumer involvement in the implementation of recovery-oriented practice.
以康复为导向的实践已成为国际精神卫生服务的主导模式。但在以医院为基础的精神卫生服务中,这种模式仍有例外,因为在这种情况下,高发病率和安全问题仍是关注重点,生物医学模式仍占主导地位。本综述旨在确定在以医院为基础的精神卫生服务中实施以康复为导向的实践的方法和可行性。对文献(2010-2019 年)进行系统回顾,确定了 17 项关于以医院为基础的精神卫生服务中实施以康复为导向的实践的研究。其中一项研究因质量评估被排除在外。在其余的研究中,有 7 项报告了员工培训计划,4 项报告了由员工促进的服务用户计划,5 项是实施护理模式。研究结果表明,在以医院为基础的精神卫生服务中实施以康复为导向的实践是可行的,尽管具有挑战性。更成功的方法是多模式的,经过几年的实施,并得到组织的支持。实施的主要障碍包括对既定的生物医学模式的抵制、员工对康复的态度以及消费者在实施以康复为导向的实践中缺乏参与。