Ahiyevets Sviatlana, Shpakou Andrei, Baj-Korpak Joanna, Kleszczewska Ewa, Rzatkiewicz Katarzyna, Mancewicz Krzysztof, Stetsenko Valentina, Stetsenko Semen
Institute of Legal Research, National Centre of Legislation and Legal Research of the Republic of Belarus, Minsk, Belarus.
Yanka Kupala State University of Grodno, Grodno, Belarus.
Osong Public Health Res Perspect. 2020 Oct;11(5):286-295. doi: 10.24171/j.phrp.2020.11.5.04.
This study aimed to determine the reasons for student dissatisfaction with the quality of primary healthcare (PHC) in countries under healthcare system transformation (Belarus, Poland, and Ukraine) to identify reserves and make improvements.
A comparative multipopulation survey was translated, verified, and completed during face-to-face interviews during March 2019 to May 2019. There were 700 Humanities students included in this study to determine satisfaction with the quality of PHC provided by the family doctor. Satisfaction was assessed according to the availability of the doctor, the level of organization of the institution, the service process, the quality of the interaction with the doctor, adherence to the rights of patients, and any additional financial expense incurred by the patient.
Politeness and attentiveness of doctors were rated highly. Dissatisfaction was associated with the negative attitude of medical personnel towards the patient. One in 10 respondents replied that medical confidentiality was not observed. More than 65% of students had paid for diagnostic tests/or treatments, and some respondents from Poland and Ukraine were asked by the doctor to pay for services without a receipt.
Dissatisfaction with the quality of PHC in countries under transformation of the health system was largely due to ethical aspects of the doctor-patient relationship. Therefore, ethical standards need to be upheld and patients need to be aware of these standards using medical education materials covering the moral aspects of the relationship between medical personnel and patient.
本研究旨在确定医疗体系转型国家(白俄罗斯、波兰和乌克兰)的学生对初级医疗保健(PHC)质量不满的原因,以找出改进的空间并加以改善。
2019年3月至2019年5月期间,在面对面访谈中对一项比较多人群调查进行了翻译、核实并完成。本研究纳入了700名人文学科学生,以确定他们对家庭医生提供的初级医疗保健质量的满意度。根据医生的可及性、机构的组织水平、服务流程、与医生互动的质量、对患者权利的遵守情况以及患者产生的任何额外财务费用来评估满意度。
医生的礼貌和专注度得到了高度评价。不满与医务人员对患者的消极态度有关。十分之一的受访者表示医疗保密未得到遵守。超过65%的学生支付了诊断测试/治疗费用,波兰和乌克兰的一些受访者被医生要求付费但未收到收据。
医疗体系转型国家对初级医疗保健质量的不满很大程度上归因于医患关系的伦理方面。因此,需要坚持道德标准,并通过涵盖医务人员与患者关系道德方面的医学教育材料让患者了解这些标准。