Department of Family Medicine, Hue University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Hue University, Hue, Vietnam.
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Ghent University, Gent, Belgium.
PLoS One. 2020 Oct 29;15(10):e0241311. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0241311. eCollection 2020.
Measuring the performance of a primary care system is one of the very first steps to find out whether there is room for improvement. To obtain an objective and comprehensive view, this measurement should come from both the supply and demand sides of the system. Patients' experiences of primary care have been studied around the world, but much less energy has been invested in researching providers' perspectives. This research aims to explore how primary care physicians working at commune health centers in Vietnam evaluate their performance and their opinions on how to improve the quality of primary care services.
First, a quantitative study was conducted using the validated Vietnamese PCAT questionnaire-provider expanded version (VN PCAT PE) targeting all primary care physicians (PCPs) working at commune health centers in a province of Central Vietnam. Next, a qualitative study was carried out, consisting of in-depth interviews with PCPs, to better understand the results of the quantitative survey and gain insight on barriers of primary care services and how to overcome them.
In the quantitative portion of our study, 150 PCPs rated the quality of ongoing care and first contact in CHCs as the best (3.09 and 3.11 out of 4, respectively), and coordination as the worst performing core domain (2.53). Twenty-two PCPs also participated in our qualitative research. In regards to challenges that primary care physicians face during their daily practice, three central themes emerged: 1) patient factors such as client attitude and knowledge, 2) provider factors such as the burden of administrative work and lack of training opportunities, and 3) contextual factors such as low income and lack of resources including medicines and diagnostics. Participants recommended more health promotion campaigns in the media, increasing the number of services available at CHCs (such as being able to take blood samples), reducing the workload related to administration for CHC leaders, greater government subsidies, and providing more training courses for PCPs.
Findings from this study offer a valuable view from the supply-side of the primary care system, specifically those who directly deliver primary care services. Along with the earlier study on consumers' evaluation of the Vietnamese primary care system, and literature from other low and middle-income countries, these findings offer emerging evidence for policymakers to improve the quality of primary care in Vietnam.
衡量初级保健系统的绩效是找出改进空间的首要步骤之一。为了获得客观全面的观点,这种衡量应该来自系统的供应方和需求方。世界各地都研究了患者对初级保健的体验,但在研究提供者的观点方面投入的精力要少得多。这项研究旨在探讨越南社区卫生中心的初级保健医生如何评估他们的绩效,以及他们对如何提高初级保健服务质量的看法。
首先,对越南中部某省社区卫生中心工作的所有初级保健医生(PCP)使用经过验证的越南 PCAT 问卷-提供者扩展版(VN PCAT PE)进行了一项定量研究。接下来,进行了一项定性研究,包括对 PCP 的深入访谈,以更好地理解定量调查的结果,并深入了解初级保健服务的障碍以及如何克服这些障碍。
在我们的研究的定量部分,150 名 PCP 将 CHC 中正在进行的护理和首次接触的质量评为最佳(分别为 4 分中的 3.09 分和 3.11 分),协调被评为表现最差的核心领域(2.53 分)。22 名 PCP 还参加了我们的定性研究。关于初级保健医生在日常实践中面临的挑战,出现了三个核心主题:1)患者因素,如客户态度和知识,2)提供者因素,如行政工作负担和缺乏培训机会,3)背景因素,如收入低和缺乏资源,包括药品和诊断。参与者建议在媒体上开展更多的健康促进活动,增加 CHC 提供的服务数量(例如能够采集血样),减少 CHC 领导的行政工作量,增加政府补贴,并为 PCP 提供更多培训课程。
这项研究的结果提供了初级保健系统供应方的宝贵观点,特别是那些直接提供初级保健服务的人。结合之前对越南初级保健系统消费者评估的研究以及来自其他中低收入国家的文献,这些发现为政策制定者提供了改进越南初级保健质量的新证据。